Should Finasteride Be Recommended to Every Man to Prevent Prostate Cancer?

A study in the British medical journal New England Journal of Medicine found regular finasteride reduced overall prostate cancer risk by %30 but did not prolong survival or prevent advanced prostate cancer.
Prostate cancer is among men's most common and deadliest cancers. Many unknowns, uncertainty about ideal treatments and treatment side effects substantially impairing quality of life make prevention a priority.
Prevention first requires identifying causes. Genetic and environmental factors contribute, but their precise nature remains unclear. Few drugs are therefore established as preventive. Finasteride, the first shown in controlled studies to reduce risk, is among these few. It inhibits an enzyme involved in androgen production, reducing male hormone levels. Given androgens' role in prostate cancer, its preventive potential seems strong. This study examined the extent of that effect.
Healthy men aged 60-65, 18.880 in total, were divided into 2 groups; one received regular finasteride for 7 years, the other did not. They were followed for 18 years. Prostate cancer occurred in 989 finasteride recipients versus 1412 controls. However, advanced cancers numbered 333 in the finasteride group and 286 in controls. Overall cancer was less frequent with finasteride, but advanced cancer was more frequent. Survival did not differ significantly, suggesting it mainly prevents low-risk tumors.
In conclusion, although apparently preventive, finasteride raises doubts about widespread use. It probably prevents only low-risk tumors that would pose little threat untreated, as many studies suggest. It may suit high-risk individuals, but even for them confident recommendation is premature. Recommending a drug to a population without clear, reliable data exposes that population to all known and unknown effects. Caution in recommending or using such unproven drugs is advisable; otherwise, trying to protect health may cost it.
Sources
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.