3 Examples of the Healthiest and Unhealthiest Diets – What Should You Consider When Choosing a Diet?

As in every year, many diets promising rapid weight loss gained popularity in 2020 despite appearing unhealthy. Healthy, balanced diets may not be as popular as diets that produce rapid weight loss and severely restrict foods. However, following healthy diets is the best approach to staying healthy and maintaining lasting weight control.
Regardless of the diet chosen, following these suggestions can help you feel fuller and lose weight more quickly and permanently:
• Ensure adequate water intake: Drinking enough water helps you feel fuller by taking up space in the stomach and helps the body eliminate edema. Although water requirements vary with factors such as physical activity and age, drinking at least 1.5 - 2 liters of water daily is recommended.
• Limit sugar consumption: According to the American Heart Association, women's daily sugar intake should be less than 20 grams and men's less than 35 grams. Daily sugar consumption worldwide is much higher than these figures. It is therefore helpful to limit sugar by not adding it to coffee, avoiding sugary drinks and packaged foods, and choosing healthier dessert alternatives.
• Increase vegetable consumption: Vegetables have countless benefits and increase fiber intake and therefore fullness. The antioxidants obtained from vegetables also provide many benefits.
• Increase physical activity: Alongside choosing low-calorie foods for healthy, lasting weight loss, increasing physical activity to burn more calories daily is very helpful. Daily 30-minute exercise that raises the heart rate helps achieve a calorie deficit.
• Recognize why you eat and eat only when genuinely hungry: For example, lunch eaten 4-5 hours after breakfast is consumed because of hunger, whereas eating cookies every afternoon is a habit rather than a response to hunger.
Let us look together at the 3 healthiest diets that are easy to follow and 3 unhealthy diets to avoid:
3 healthy dietary patterns
Mediterranean Diet
Although discovered in the 1960s, this dietary pattern, frequently discussed especially over the last 10 years, includes all food groups in a balanced, healthy way. It is followed as a lifestyle by people eating healthily in Mediterranean countries such as Greece, Spain and Italy. The Mediterranean diet is a very healthy, sustainable diet that does not require calorie counting.
This dietary pattern generally recommends vegetables, fruit, legumes, olive oil and nuts, making it rich in antioxidants, vitamins and minerals. Fish is recommended as the primary protein source. Lean chicken/turkey/red meat/low-fat yogurt or cheese are also allowed in certain amounts. For a closer look at the Mediterranean dietary pattern, see here.
Many studies assessing the relationship between the Mediterranean diet and health concluded that this dietary pattern has positive effects on obesity, diabetes, cancer, cardiovascular disease and the digestive system (Health Benefits and Metabolic Effects of the Mediterranean Diet is discussed in our related article).
Volumetric Diet
Developed by health experts at Pennsylvania State University in the United States, this dietary pattern aims to increase fullness by allowing more food to be consumed within daily calorie requirements. Named after volumetry, a unit used to measure the volume of objects, the volumetric diet evaluates foods by volume rather than calories. Another aim is to increase fullness by raising fiber intake through fruit and vegetables. For example, rather than eating 1 small chocolate cookie containing 200 calories, you can increase fullness and support your health by eating 1 large bowl of homemade fruit yogurt with the same calories.
Flexitarian Diet
The flexitarian diet is based on plant-based eating. Its main difference from vegetarian and vegan diets is that its rules are less strict. Its name therefore combines the words flexible and vegetarian. Plant foods form its basis, but limited animal foods are also included. This makes the flexitarian diet much more sustainable than a vegetarian diet. It is worth remembering that vegan and vegetarian foods are not always healthy choices. For example, some packaged potato chips and cookies are vegan but very high in fat and sugar. For a more detailed look at the flexitarian diet, our related article can be visited).
Dietary patterns that should not be followed long term
Fad diets are fashionable diets generally aiming at rapid but unhealthy weight loss. Let us look together at these diets, which often enter our lives through celebrities and gain popularity on social media:
Ketogenic Diet
The ketogenic diet has generated many social media reports claiming positive health effects and has prompted debate. It was developed to reduce seizures in pediatric epilepsy patients. Recently, however, it has been claimed to benefit health and be suitable for weight loss. Fat is the main energy source in this diet, while carbohydrate intake is very low. Higher-fat protein sources are chosen to keep fat intake high. Removing sugar from the diet is, of course, very beneficial. However, this diet also limits healthy carbohydrates rich in vitamins, minerals and fiber, such as vegetables, fruit and legumes. It can therefore be very harmful to health. Rather than almost completely removing carbohydrates, a basic bodily requirement, causing vitamin/mineral deficiencies and making the body function against its accustomed mechanisms:
• Following dietary patterns that include all food groups in a healthy, balanced way will be much more beneficial.
Dukan Diet
The Dukan diet aims for rapid weight loss through high protein and low carbohydrate intake. Although carbohydrates are not as low as in the ketogenic diet, intake is still insufficient. Low-carbohydrate diets such as Dukan or ketogenic diets can cause rapid weight loss in the first weeks, but this is due not only to fat loss but largely to water loss. An average of 3 grams of water is retained in the body for every 1 gram of glycogen, the stored form of carbohydrate. On low-carbohydrate diets, the body depletes glycogen stores before protein or fat stores. When glycogen stores are used, the released water is excreted. This can produce rapid weight loss on the scales in the first weeks. However, when carbohydrates are consumed again, the lost water is replaced, so weight loss is not permanent.
- Related topic: A Low-Carbohydrate or Keto Diet May Shorten Lifespan
Alkaline Diet
Although foods in the alkaline diet are healthy, its claimed positive health effects are not based on scientific evidence. This diet targets the body's acid-base balance. Some foods can make urine acidic and others alkaline, and this diet recommends alkaline foods. Products such as meat/milk/grains are limited or removed because they are more acidic. With many alkaline vegetables and fruits, it is high in fiber, vitamins and minerals and can consequently produce weight loss. However, limiting many protein-rich foods means some vitamin and mineral requirements are often not met. Research also shows that when kidneys function healthily, foods consumed affect only whether urine is acidic or alkaline, not the blood (for detailed information about the alkaline diet and its effect on cancer, our related article can be visited).
Summary and Commentary
Looking at recommendations for healthy, lasting weight loss with greater fullness, we can see that the Mediterranean dietary pattern includes them all. Rather than popular diets with strict rules or promises of rapid weight loss at the expense of health, we recommend losing weight by following the Mediterranean diet, which has been extensively researched and has proven positive effects. If you want to limit animal products for various reasons, you could also try the Flexiteranean dietary pattern. Because it does not completely exclude any food group, vitamin and mineral deficiencies that may occur with vegan or vegetarian diets are much less likely. Although the volumetric diet's rationale is very sensible, learning food volumes and calories and comparing them in everyday life can be quite laborious.
*
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.