Fear of Cancer Recurrence Tends to Increase Over Time in Those Diagnosed Young

A Belgian study published in Psycho-Oncology shows younger, less optimistic breast cancer survivors experience more fear of recurrence over time.
According to the study, recurrence fear tends to rise in younger women during the first year after breast cancer surgery.
Innovations in breast cancer treatment have brought 5-year survival to around %90, with more people recovering and living longer. After treatment, people experience positive and negative emotions: greater gratitude for life, but also sadness and fear of recurrence.
Recurrence fear follows no fixed timeline. Earlier research suggests it may remain stable or decrease over time depending on cancer type, treatment and study timing. Age, physical symptoms/performance and optimism were previously found to be its strongest influences.
Fear can strongly affect emotional and psychological well-being and, if unaddressed, quality of life. Researchers studied how age and optimism influence fear over time in women with a history of breast cancer as participants.
Study Design
The study included women aged 20-80, totaling 267 recently diagnosed patients. They were invited while attending a Belgian hospital for breast surgery. All operations occurred 5 to 10 days after diagnosis.
Participants completed several questionnaires. The Concerns About Recurrence Scale measures recurrence fear. The Life Orientation Testmeasures optimism, or the tendency to feel positively about the future. Participants also supplied age, marital status and education. Questionnaires were completed after surgery but before discharge. They repeated the Concerns About Recurrence Scale at 6 and 18 months after surgery.
Study Results
- All participants experienced recurrence fear during the first 6 months after surgery.
- After 6 months, older women reported less fear than in previous research.
- But after 6 months, younger women's fear worsened.
- At month 18, younger women's fear was still increasing, exceeding immediately postoperative and 6-month levels.
Researchers suggested immediate postoperative relief might explain this. As time passes, people refocus on the future, and younger women may have more future concerns. Life Orientation Test results showed optimistic participants had less recurrence fear than less optimistic ones. Optimism may influence coping: optimistic people are more likely to accept illness early and find positive coping methods. They are also less likely to develop anxiety as a condition. Researchers believe the findings may help people struggling with recurrence fear.
Study Limitations
The study has weaknesses:
The first questionnaire was completed immediately after surgery; scores might differ a week before or after. Researchers also used a shortened Concerns About Recurrence Scale. The study is observational, and other factors may affect outcomes.
What Does This Mean for You?
If diagnosed young or inclined to expect the worst, future fear that cancer will returnmay increase during and after treatment. However, some degree of recurrence fear is a completely normal emotional response during cancer.
Everyone has different triggers for this fear. Be patient identifying yours, since healthy, effective coping strategies take time. For information and tips, see 6 Tips for Coping With Fear of Cancer Recurrence as our article.
Be honest with your doctor, loved ones and yourself to obtain needed support. Young women and partners can reduce fear by discussing cancer worries. Consider consulting a psycho-oncology specialist.
Sources
The course of fear of cancer recurrence: Different patterns by age in breast cancer survivors.
Psycho-Oncology. July 2017.
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.