Has China Eliminated COVID-19? Or Is It Trying to Hide a Worsening Situation?

China's Zero-COVID Policy Is Going Badly
China's Beijing Daily newspaper published on 29.10.2021 a complex chart of two people with COVID-19 and everyone they infected, including details of the Delta variant currently spreading in the country.
Since the first coronavirus cases were reported about two years ago, China has pursued a zero-tolerance COVID policy. China's success in preventing the virus from spreading widely across the country stands in stark contrast to the situation in most Western countries. Since last year, fewer than 100,000 cases have officially been reported in a population of approximately 1.4 billion, and at least 4,634 people have died.
By comparison, the United States reported approximately 46 million cases and more than 740,000 deaths, while England reported about 9 million cases and more than 140,000 deaths.
What Is China's Zero-COVID Policy, and What Measures Has It Taken?
In China, however, the policy continues to be pursued intensively.
Even for a small number of cases, China's radical measures include:
- closing borders,
- quarantines in local areas,
- travel restrictions and
- mass testing of tens of millions of people within days.
Chinese citizens living abroad who want to return to China frequently have their flights canceled at the last minute. On Thursday, for example, a high-speed train from Shanghai was ordered to stop halfway, before reaching Beijing, immediately after an official was found to have been in close contact with a patient who tested positive for COVID-19. All 211 other passengers on the train were immediately quarantined at designated sites.
But as the world decides to live with the virus, mitigated by vaccines, and gradually begins reopening, China remains one of the few countries committed to completely eliminating it. Analysts and health experts are beginning to discuss how long this outbreak can last, and the latest outbreak, which began in early October, is once again testing the limits.
As of Friday, October 29, the latest Delta outbreak had infected more than 300 people in 12 provinces, including the capital Beijing, in just over a week. The outbreak was centered in Inner Mongolia and linked to travelers. In response, authorities launched mass testing, halted transport and imposed local quarantines.
According to Yanzhong Huang, a specialist in Chinese public health policy at the Council on Foreign Relations in New York, “Scenes like this have become normal in recent months”.
What Does the Public Think about the Zero-COVID Policy?
While most people on social media support the government's approach, one Beijing resident says their fears have become part of everyday life, and another describes people “panicking” as the situation becomes more tense.
“There are bans on dining and curfews everywhere. Even eating normally is very difficult.”
Tourists stranded in Ejina Banner, Inner Mongolia, are also sharing their frustration on social media. Last Saturday, a tour leader said guests had been stranded for six days and some elderly participants had run out of medication. Another claimed that some guests were showing symptoms but there was no medical facility nearby.
“It seems Ejina Banner does not care whether people live or die.”
Professor Chunhuei Chi, director of the Center for Global Health at Oregon State University, said, “People are beginning to dwindle. As everywhere else in the world, we can see that we have been dragged through this pandemic for about two years and can observe pandemic fatigue everywhere. This certainly affects the Chinese public too.” .
The latest crisis is the second major outbreak this year linked to the highly contagious Delta variant; both outbreaks spread to multiple cities. During the first Delta-related outbreak in Yangzhou this summer, rare public unrest was reported because the government failed to supply food to residents in an area closed for three weeks.
Meanwhile, some Chinese public health experts have begun suggesting that China consider moving toward a policy of living with the virus. Although their comments received some support from citizens and counterparts, they were harshly criticized and suppressed by the government.
China Blamed for the Pandemic
Chi said the Chinese government was sticking to its strategies because it had no other political option. Referring to energy shortages and the housing-sector crisis, he said ensuring there was no major COVID outbreak was, at home, “probably the last bastion of credibility and legitimacy”. But Chi said there was another impetus stemming from international blame directed at China for the pandemic itself.
“From the beginning, China has persistently wanted to show the world its capacity and credibility in controlling this outbreak. They want to demonstrate how successfully China has brought the outbreak under control and its ability to mobilize all available resources. They want to be seen as the savior rather than the cause.”
There is still support for the government's efforts. Urging everyone to look at the bigger picture, one social media user said, “Personal freedom, personal business, privacy, dignity and mental health can be sacrificed”.
Beijing acknowledged that the pandemic was the greatest challenge for the Winter Olympics in February and the Winter Paralympics in March. Recently published guidance said participants would quarantine before entering the competition world's “closed loop”, completely separated from the rest of China to prevent cross-infection.
Chi said China could use its accumulated wealth to keep the country going for another year. “People, especially a large share of those in low- and middle-income groups, are already suffering. They cannot sustain this. Restricting their mobility and economic activities will further worsen their livelihoods.”
Huang said that, to some extent, Beijing was also facing a dilemma. “We have seen flare-ups in countries such as Singapore that adopted a 'living with COVID' approach. If this also happens in China, people will turn to the government and ask, 'Why did you fail to protect us?' This is the last thing China wants to see, especially with the Winter Olympics approaching early next year.”
Sources
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.