How Appropriate Is the Approach “I Have Breast Cancer, Remove My Entire Breast and Save Me”?

According to a study presented at the San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium in December 2015, breast-conserving surgery followed by radiotherapy provides higher survival rates in early-stage breast cancer than conventional mastectomy. Radiotherapy administered after this technique also results in lower rates of recurrence and spread to distant tissues.
There is a situation I frequently observe in women newly diagnosed with breast cancer that is extremely important when determining the type of surgery to be performed. A woman facing cancer is naturally afraid and primarily wants to save her life. I also see that patients are somehow angry with their breast because it has caused cancer and is threatening their life. These two perceptions create a desire to get rid of that breast as soon as possible. For these reasons, many patients expect surgeons to remove the breast completely rather than remove part of it through what we call breast-conserving surgery, or partial mastectomy.
Two misconceptions feed this feeling in a woman with breast cancer. The first social misconception is the belief that completely removing the cancerous breast will eliminate the possibility of another tumor developing in the future. The second is that, whatever happens, she has tissue that has harmed her and with which she is angry, and she wants to get rid of it. A patient experiencing these feelings usually chooses a mastectomy operation involving complete removal of the breast if she does not meet a surgeon skilled in breast cancer. Imagine how distressing it is for a woman with a 1 cm tumor to lose her entire breast. After recovery from breast cancer, although her fear initially focuses entirely on cancer, her later feelings will involve unhappiness, anxiety, disruption of bodily integrity and harm to her sexual self-perception. At precisely this point, the study discussed in our article has shed light on this confusion. We oncologists now have a very strong response to a surgical approach based on this thinking and to these patient concerns.
In breast cancer, the most common cancer type among women, surgical removal of the cancerous tissue from the body at an early stage forms the basis of treatment. Although there are several options at this point, 2 surgical approaches generally stand out: mastectomy, in which the breast tissue is completely removed, and breast-conserving surgery (lumpectomy), in which only the tumor is removed together with some surrounding healthy tissue.
The greatest advantage of breast-conserving surgery is preservation of most of the patient’s breast and achievement of a better appearance. The greatest concern about this method was that the remaining breast tissue could serve as a potential haven for cancer cells, with recurrence rates reaching 30%. However, postoperative radiotherapy resolved this problem, and thousands of studies conducted over more than 20 years have shown that patients choosing mastectomy do not live longer than those undergoing breast-conserving surgery followed by radiotherapy. Thus, breast-conserving surgery has been shown to provide a much better cosmetic result while being no less effective than mastectomy. However, the new study discussed here has taken breast-conserving surgery a step further and shown that it may also be superior to mastectomy in terms of survival.
In the study, 22 thousand women underwent breast-conserving surgery followed by radiotherapy, and 15 thousand underwent mastectomy, among a total of 37 thousand women with early-stage breast cancer whose 10-year survival rates and rates of disease recurrence and spread (metastasis) were assessed. The results showed a 10-year survival rate of approximately 77% in patients undergoing breast-conserving surgery followed by radiotherapy and approximately 60% in those undergoing mastectomy. Disease recurrence and metastasis were also more frequent in the mastectomy group. This difference was associated with radiotherapy administered after breast-conserving surgery.
In conclusion, this study suggests that breast-conserving surgery is more effective, beyond merely having effectiveness similar to mastectomy. At this point, breast-conserving surgery, which offers both high effectiveness and better cosmetic results, should be the preferred method in these patients unless there is an obstacle. Nevertheless, this remains a personal decision and should be made through a comprehensive assessment by the patient, relatives and physician.
Sources
Higher 10-year overall survival after breast conserving therapy compared to mastectomy in early stage breast cancer: A population-based study with 37,207 patients.
2015 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium. December 8–12. Abstract S3-05
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.