We Should Protect Young Breast Cancer Patients from Unnecessary Mastectomy

A study presented at the December 2018 San Antonio Breast Cancer Conference showed that the increasingly common approaches of "completely emptying the inside of the breast" or "completely removing both breasts for prevention" cause more harm than good in young patients with breast cancer.
A patient diagnosed with breast cancer, with the anxiety and concern of facing cancer, often asks the surgeon for operations thought to minimize cancer recurrence risk, such as removal of both breasts or complete emptying of the breast. We see that in recent years these requests can be met by surgeons who are not competent in this field. Alternatively, surgeons specializing in breast cancer surgery may become caught up in the financial gratification of offering complex operations to their patients. We observe these approaches being preferred more often by physicians working outside multidisciplinary teams.
Details of the Study
Between October 2016 and November 2017, researchers administered the BREAST-Q questionnaire to patients diagnosed with stage 0 to stage III breast cancer, totaling 561 women [these patients were enrolled in a prospective clinical study]. The median age at diagnosis was 37.
BREAST-Q scores measuring satisfaction with breast appearance, physical, psychosocial and sexual well-being were compared across different types of breast cancer surgery, including bilateral mastectomy, unilateral mastectomy and breast-conserving surgery. Among participating women, % 28 had breast-conserving surgery and % 72 had mastectomy. Among women who underwent mastectomy, % 72 had bilateral breast surgery and % 89 had reconstructive (plastic) surgery.
- Related topic: Types of breast cancer surgery (in detail)
The study found that, mean BREAST-Q scores for breast satisfaction and psychosocial or sexual well-being in women undergoing mastectomy or bilateral mastectomy, compared with those undergoing breast-conserving surgery, were lower . Physical functioning was similar in all three groups.

In the figure above , as shown, breast satisfaction and psychosocial or sexual well-being scores are higher with breast-conserving surgery.
In conclusion, in young women with breast cancer, mastectomy operations involving complete removal or emptying of one or both breasts may have lasting negative effects on satisfaction with breast appearance and psychosocial and sexual outcomes. Therefore, when guiding young women in surgical decisions, they should be informed about the potential long-term effects of treatment options, and unnecessary excessive surgery should be avoided.
Related Topic:
Sources
SABCS 2018: Surgical Choice May Impact Long-Term Quality of Life in Young Adults With Breast Cancer.
ascopost.com - 7 December 2018
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.