What Is the Effect of a Second Opinion from a Specialist Radiologist on the Treatment and Staging of Head and Neck Cancers?

Although head and neck cancers involve organs very close to one another, they show surprising differences in medical management, radiotherapy treatment and radiological assessment. For example, tumors of the paranasal sinuses, the cavities in the face, are completely different from other head and neck tumors. The course and treatment of tumors in the front of the tongue also differ from those at its base. Although laryngeal cancer is classified among head and neck cancers, its treatments differ according to the region within the larynx where the tumor is located. These examples can be extended to cancers of the lips and soft palate. These diseases are cancers that appear adjacent and closely related, yet almost all have different behavioral characteristics and naturally require different treatment approaches.
Although treatment options may appear limited, the timing and combinations of surgery, radiotherapy, chemotherapy or smart-drug treatment are extremely important in saving patients’ lives. The right treatment combinations given in the right sequence can be lifesaving.
Although treating these closely situated cancers of the head and neck region may seem straightforward for any physician, their radiological assessment, medical treatment decisions and surgery require considerable experience. Today we will present a study with surprising results.
A study published in the “Journal of Otolaryngology - Head & Neck Surgery” demonstrated differences between assessment of films showing disease extent, namely radiological imaging, by a radiologist specializing in head and neck cancers (a neuroradiologist) and by a general radiologist in patients with head and neck cancer.
The research determined the effects on cancer staging and patient management of a second opinion provided by a specialist radiologist on head and neck imaging studies performed at another healthcare institution.
The study examined original and second-opinion reports for 94 patients with head and neck cancer. The rates of differences in staging and recommended patient management were calculated.
A second opinion from a radiologist specializing in head and neck cancers changed cancer staging in 56% of patients (among 94 cases, 53). Recommended treatment also changed in 38% of patients with head and neck cancer (among 94 cases, 36). Compared with postoperative pathological staging, the gold standard, the second opinion was correct in 93% (among 30 cases, 28).
As the study’s results show, evaluating cancer imaging requires highly competent teamwork. If this assessment is not performed by the right people, serious errors can occur from the very beginning, in the radiological imaging describing cancer distribution. Good medical treatment for cancer cannot be provided without good imaging. Therefore, as with other cancers, head and neck cancers should be assessed by radiologists competent in this field. Medical oncologists committed to this field must also plan the entire treatment process with a multidisciplinary team of competent professionals such as a surgeon, radiation oncologist, dietitian, pathologist and radiologist.
Sources
Impact of neuroradiologist second opinion on staging and management of head and neck cancer.
J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2013 Jun 5;42:39. doi: 10.1186/1916-0216-42-39.
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.