Where Did the New Coronavirus Come from and How Did It Emerge? The Whole Process in Brief

When Chinese scientists alerted colleagues to a new virus last December, suspicion fell on a market in the city of Wuhan. What have we learned since then?
The Beginning: A Different New Year
Maria van Kerkhove was with her sister in the United States for the Christmas holiday. She was checking her emails as usual. As a World Health Organization (WHO) virologist who would become a familiar name and face within weeks, she said there were signals of potential problems every day.
“There is always something at Christmas. There is always a signal or alert about something suspicious. For the last few years, there was Mers (Middle East respiratory syndrome) — a suspected travel case from the Middle East to Malaysia, India, Korea or somewhere in Asia. So there is always some kind of signal. There is always something going on,” she said.
Checking these reports of suspected infections is routine for Van Kerkhove and a select group of experts including Christian Drosten in Germany, Marion Koopmans in the Netherlands, people at Public Health in England and the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Van Kerhhove said, “I have become used to this during holidays” . “They are usually not very important. But this was different.”
A Cluster of Pneumonia Cases of Unknown Origin
In midwinter, a cluster of pneumonia cases of unknown origin was reported in China. The email was sent by the International Society for Infectious Diseases' alert network , called ProMED . On the evening of 30 December, the Wuhan Municipal Health Commission warned all medical facilities to be on alert and activate emergency plans.
Van Kerkhove said: “We immediately knew this was something to take seriously and instantly activated our systems.” She has not stopped working since. Within days they understood it was not Sars , not Mers , not influenza, Legionella or any of a range of other pathogens. This was new.
Van Kerkhove, who meticulously describes pandemic developments twice a week in WHO's Zoom briefings, is a respiratory infection specialist who has worked on coronaviruses, including Mers, for a long time. Var Kerkhove said: “I immediately thought this could be a new coronavirus because there are literally hundreds, even thousands, of types of coronavirus circulating in animals.” Coronaviruses were therefore already in WHO's detailed blueprint for needed outbreak research. The danger was there and had been known since the Sars pandemic in 2003.
We know that, by the time Van Kerkhove saw the email, at least 124 people had fallen ill and some had died in Hubei province after contracting a new virus to which people were vulnerable. Some would have been infected in mid-November. Almost all (119) were in the provincial capital, Wuhan. The other five had been there before becoming ill. Wuhan had excellent surveillance and a first-class biosafety laboratory that would later come under suspicion. The cluster was detected in Wuhan, but it was still possible that it had come from somewhere else.
- Related Topic: The 12 Deadliest Viral Outbreaks
Patient Zero (the First Patient)
The person who first spread the disease may never be found. The first victim of the Ebola outbreak in East Africa turned out to be a baby named Emile Ouamouno, who died in a remote part of Guinea in December 2013. But Ebola was so deadly and, unlike most other diseases, so easy to identify. What is now called Covid-19 resembled acute pneumonia when it seriously affected frail and elderly people, and the first people to contract it may have shown no symptoms.
Did Coronavirus Emerge from the Animal Market?
The first clue was the animal market, but what initially seemed a definite cause is now uncertain. Of a sample of 41 early detected cases, 70% were regular customers, employees or owners of Huanan Seafood Market, where seafood was sold along with live animals caught illegally and slaughtered in front of customers.
The animal market was closed by Chinese authorities on 1 January, thoroughly cleaned and disinfected, helping hygiene but also destroying clues. However, swab tests showed traces of the virus in areas where wild animals had been kept. In late January, an inventory from a domestic and wild animal shop in the market emerged, giving a flavor of the trade. The list included live wolf cubs, golden cicadas, scorpions, bamboo rats, squirrels, foxes, “kalemisleri”, salamanders, frogs and crocodiles among the animals. Crocodile tails, bellies, tongues and intestines were among the various animal parts sold.
China Recognized the Virus's Threat Early, but Many Western Countries Did Not Understand It for Months
Nevertheless, It Is Not Certain That the Virus Came from the Market. Although nobody believes Chinese state media's latest claims that someone may have come from outside the country's borders, it is possible that an infected person traveled to China. Foreign Ministry spokesperson Zhao Lijian said in late November: "Although China was the first country to report cases, this does not mean that the virus originated in China". "Tracing the source of infection is an ongoing process that may involve several countries and regions."
Knowing is important for the safety of the whole world. WHO has been investigating since the outbreak began. In January, a door-to-door investigation would have been the best starting point, speaking to the first people who became ill in Wuhan, their families and colleagues. But the city was in lockdown and the streets were deserted. The Canadian doctor and epidemiologist appointed by WHO to lead its information-gathering mission to China in early February, Bruce Aylward, said the rest of the world did not yet understand what it was facing.
Aylward said, "From the moment you landed in China, you knew you were facing something very serious that the rest of the world did not understand. You got off the plane and were in an empty Beijing airport. It was absolutely striking: your footsteps echoed through the enormous halls of Beijing airport, normally full day and night".
Alyward was shaken by how seriously the government took the outbreak and the cost to the country in every sense of such a comprehensive lockdown, including closed borders. At that stage, however, China was doing what it had to do — and what many countries had failed to do. It was not looking for the source; it was eliminating the virus.
But on 11 January, Chinese scientists gave the world an invaluable clue. On the day the first death was reported (a man who regularly visited the market), the genetic sequence of the new virus was published.
This sequence and many others since have suggested that at least the distant ancestor of Sars-CoV-2 — as it had been named — was likely in horseshoe bats in China's Yunnan province. Samples collected and stored after Sars show that the RaTG13 bat virus is, compared with the new one causing Covid-19, 96% similar in those comparisons.
This is not enough. As with Sars and Mers, both bat-origin coronaviruses, there must be an intermediate host. In March, virologist Eddie Holmes, Andrew Rambaut and others published a review in Nature of what could be inferred from the genetic data. In particular, the new coronavirus's famous spike protein has a region that attaches to a particular receptor in a human cell, called ACE2. This region is known as a "receptor-binding domain" . Bat viruses do not have this. However, they pointed out that coronaviruses in Malayan pangolins do have it.

Pangolins came under suspicion, but they were not listed at the Huanan market, although that did not prove they were absent. However, they could somehow transmit such a virus to humans, and other possible animals are much more familiar to us.
For WHO, which launched an official inquiry in the summer, the questions of which species could be intermediaries and whether there might be a permanent virus reservoir are critical. The terms of reference published in July stated: "Susceptibility studies in several countries so far have shown that domestic cats, ferrets, hamsters and mink are particularly susceptible to infection." Cats can acquire the virus and transmit it to other cats. Approximately 14% of more than 100 cats tested in Wuhan had positive samples. Mink, famous for their fur, were found to carry the virus — first in Denmark and the Netherlands, then in Europe and the United States — and were rounded up.
Did It Escape from a Laboratory?
Despite strong genomic indications/evidence that the new coronavirus evolved from animals, sensational theories blaming China on right-wing news sites and social media in April claimed that the virus had been made in the Wuhan Institute of Virology laboratory. An author making this claim, Kristian Andersen of the Scripps Research Institute in California, was removed from his positions at Nature.
"Our analyses clearly show that Sars-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct or a deliberately manipulated virus.” Wellcome's epidemic lead, Josie Golding, said it was important to say this: "A group of leading researchers has come together to explain why we do not think this is a virus made in a laboratory: because you would never make a virus like this, and there are too many connections with other viruses found in nature."
Golding, who works at a high-containment facility in Pirbright, Surrey, said there was also no possibility that it had accidentally escaped from the Wuhan laboratory. The idea that a person could become infected in the laboratory and spread it around the world belonged in films, she said. "Show me the evidence... It does not seem very realistic. It is much more likely that animals became infected and people caught the virus from them."
However it began, the advantage was that China and other Asian countries recognized the threat. Aylward said many Western countries still did not understand in the early months. Having experienced Sars, China was now experienced and concerned.
If there are 1000 cases in the West, it will hospitalize the 100 severe ones. Nobody has any idea where the other 900 people are, so you cannot win this way… The biggest difference between Central Asian countries such as China and Singapore and the West is their extraordinary effort to isolate all moderate and mild cases effectively.
Regardless of where it came from — or who is blamed — the only way to deal with a new virus is to take it incredibly seriously. Few countries treated it as a serious virus from the first day.
*
RELATED TOPICS
Sources
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.