A Bird's-Eye View of Oncology: Pigeons Eye Radiologists' and Pathologists' Jobs!

Pathologists and radiologists work for many years to acquire the professional and visual skills medically required and to become experts in their work. To develop accurate diagnostic abilities through these lengthy efforts, correctly perceiving the characteristics and qualities of pathological and radiological images of diseases is critically important.
Suitable animal models have long been used to understand human behavior. In the study discussed in this article, researchers investigated how the visual abilities of pathologists and radiologists might be better developed, using pigeons, also common in our country, of the Columba livia species. These pigeons were selected because their visual systems resemble those of humans. According to the researchers, no previous study had demonstrated pigeons' ability to observe medical images.
The study examined pigeons' ability to distinguish cancerous cells from normal cells. Pigeons were shown histopathological images of malignant and benign breast tissues and rewarded with food when they chose correctly. This revealed the pigeons' extraordinary visual ability. More importantly, when presented with different image sets, the pigeons also managed to generalize what they had learned previously.
After 1 month of training, the pigeons' success in detecting cancerous tissue reached %80, although this was not as good as human specialists. The flock's success when working together was much more impressive. When different birds were shown the same images and their predictions were combined, accuracy rose to %99, equal to expert pathologists; this was much better than a computer performing automated image analysis.
The birds' ability to identify these histological images correctly was affected by image color and the degree of compression, but these abilities were also shown to improve with further training.
Human color receptors have 3 cone types, green, blue and red. These 3 types enable color vision through their sensitivity, perceptual capacity and operating principles. Pigeons have 5 cone types, thought to allow finer color discrimination.
Training animals for advanced tasks is difficult. They may receive unintended cues from trainers or observers. For example, Clever Hans , a famous horse living in the early 20th century, was observed solving simple arithmetic problems. Later, however, it was shown that the horse did not actually perform mental calculations but perceived expectations through small changes in the reactions of people watching him. Although animals can perform extremely well under certain conditions and on certain tasks, their abilities diminish when conditions and materials change.
To avoid the Clever Hans effect, the researchers conducted their experiments in an environment with no humans visible, placing the pigeons inside a box in front of a computer screen.
In the radiology component, pigeons were also shown to have similar abilities in detecting cancer-related microcalcifications on mammograms. However, when asked to assess suspicious masses on mammograms, a task also very difficult for humans, the pigeons were found merely to memorize the image and failed when shown different examples.
The birds' successes in this field certainly do not mean pigeons are ready to become certified pathologists or radiologists; they do, however, show that pigeons are suitable helpers in understanding medical images. Various practical difficulties remain. This discovery may also help develop medical image processing and analysis tools.
Sources
Pigeons (Columba livia) as Trainable Observers of Pathology and Radiology Breast Cancer Images.
Levenson RM, Krupinski EA, Navarro VM, Wasserman EA
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.