An Experienced Older Doctor or a Young, Dynamic Doctor?

This is a question that occupies all our minds. Especially in cancer treatment or the diagnosis and treatment of a difficult noncancer illness, our efforts to find the best physician often exhaust us. We try to find guidance for choosing the right doctor. We seek friends’ recommendations and ask doctors we know for their opinions. The article we want to share here addresses precisely this subject. Although we have many questions when choosing the right physician, this article will at least offer a perspective on doctors’ age.
Although older doctors have considerable experience gained with age, some negative effects of aging also occur. Some people therefore think doctors who delay retirement should undergo mandatory tests to ensure their physical and mental fitness.
A study conducted in the United States on this subject is particularly noteworthy. It examined patients hospitalized between 2011-2014, aged over 65, totaling 736000. They were supervised by doctors with a mean age of 41, totaling 18854 physicians. Comparing mortality by physician age, the rate under doctors younger than 40 was %10.8, while under doctors aged 60 and older it was %12.1.
Although Dr. Yusuke Tsugawa, who led the study, found this difference significant, he believes the result is not entirely age-related. In Tsugawa’s view: “I think the difference stems from differences in the training young doctors receive rather than the doctors’ ages. I believe young doctors are trained to be more familiar with changing science and technology and more current in applying treatments.”
Dr. William Norcross, director of the Physician Assessment and Clinical Education Program (PACE) in San Diego, states that physicians who have become distant from current literature and recent developments join the program, but they are not all older physicians; young physicians are included as well. He attributes this to shortcomings in keeping advanced knowledge current.
Age-Related Changes That May Occur in Physicians
Some studies also suggest that care quality decreases as physicians age. Although average physician performance tends to decline with age, many older doctors are known to perform as well as or better than younger doctors. There are also physicians in their late 60s who enjoy bustling around their younger colleagues, helping them and patients, and passing on their experience.
The considerable variation we see among doctors makes age-based mandatory retirement decisions difficult. It is therefore hard to establish a clear retirement age for medicine, as many factors are involved.
Minor visual impairment, mild memory problems and age-related bone and joint problems do not pose excessively serious difficulties for a doctor’s career.
Special Health Screening for Older Doctors
According to a study conducted in 2015, physicians in America included %30.9 over 65 with active licenses. Clearly, older physicians provide a substantial part of healthcare. To obtain a medical diploma, physicians must acquire certain clinical abilities and judgment during training.
In recent years, America has developed policies for older doctors. One is the PACE program. It aims to identify age-related changes early through screening such as physical tests, history, cognitive function tests, vision and hearing, and thus keep physicians in professional life by providing early solutions rather than removing them from practice. This is because training a physician is very difficult, and skills that positively contribute to the lives of both patients and healthy people are gained only after many years of experience.
Ultimately, qualities such as wisdom, experience and compassion develop with age. We want to preserve these qualities in professional life. Experienced physicians are also very important in guiding younger doctors.
Sources
Physician age and outcomes in elderly patients in hospital in the US: observational study.
BMJ 2017;357:j1797
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.