Banning Tanning Devices Such as Sunbeds Could Save Many Lives and Money

JAMA Dermatologypublished a study according to which an outright ban on indoor tanning devices such as sunbeds in the USA, Canada, and Europe could prevent 448.000 melanomas and 9.7 million keratinocyte carcinomas (keratinocyte carcinoma is the collective term for squamous and basal cell skin cancers). The study also shows that the ban would result in aggregate cost savings of 5,7 billion dollars and productivity gains of 41,3 billion dollars. Researchers noted that indoor tanning has been banned in more than 20 countries. Australia banned commercial indoor tanning devices, while Brazil banned both commercial and private tanning devices. Note: Australia has the highest incidence of skin cancer in the world.
- Related topic: A skin cancer story: X-Men's wounds do not heal easily in real life The figure below: The 3 most common types of skin cancer, a normal mole, and their characteristics:

Tanning Beds Are NOT Safer Than the Sun! Just one tanning session in these devices can increase the risk of developing skin cancer (melanoma % 20, squamous cell carcinoma % 67, and basal cell carcinoma% 29). In the USA, 19 states have banned minors from using indoor tanning beds, and 44 states and the District of Columbia have some regulations on tanning facilities for minors. In this study, Dr. Gordon and colleagues sought to investigate how an outright ban on indoor tanning devices, a ban for minors only, or current indoor tanning levels would affect health and the economy in the USA, Europe, and Canada. The team used data from epidemiological studies based on population observations, cost reports, and official cancer registries to estimate indoor tanning prevalence, the risk of developing melanoma, and mortality from skin cancer and other causes.
Results
The model suggested that banning indoor tanning in the United States and Canada would result in 244.347 fewer melanomas (% –8.7), 89.193 fewer melanoma deaths (% –6.9), and 7.3 million fewer keratinocyte carcinomas (% –7.8). Researchers said the ban would also save 428.781 life-years, produce cost savings of 3.5 billion dollars, and deliver productivity gains of 27.5 billion dollars. If implemented in Europe, the ban was estimated to result in 203.736 fewer melanomas (% -4.9), 98.288 fewer melanoma deaths (% -4.4), and 2.4 million fewer keratinocyte carcinomas (% -4.4). Researchers also noted that Europe would see gains of 459.669 life-years, cost savings of 2.1 billion dollars, and productivity gains of 13.7 billion dollars. In addition, the model did not account for money spent implementing a ban, which could include costs associated with regulation, compliance, and buyback schemes for tanning devices.
Implications of the Study
In an interview, Dr. Gordon said the researchers conducted the study to highlight the health benefits and cost savings of regulating indoor tanning devices in North America and Europe. She said she had previously published a report in 2009 that helped Australia decide to ban such devices, but that the tanning industry was then in its infancy, which also influenced the decision to ban indoor tanning. Any ban imposed by a regulatory agency “should include everyone,” Dr. Gordon said; “banning minors is a half measure for preventing skin cancers.” The danger is not confined to children. Anyone interested in tanning should use tanning creams or sprays rather than indoor tanning devices. Consumers can control their UV exposure. Prevention is incredibly important, and skin cancer is one of the few cancers we can almost entirely prevent by protecting our skin. The same cannot be said for many other cancers. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has proposed restricting the use of indoor tanning devices by minors nationwide but has not issued a final rule, and an outright ban for the general population in the USA is less likely. I think that expanding this [proposed] ban will be difficult, given the financial impact on many businesses. Making it happen will probably require more evidence and support beyond the medical community, but we remain hopeful. Indoor tanning devices such as sunbeds were reclassified by the International Agency for Research on Cancer = IARC, an agency of the World Health Organization, in 2009 from group 2A carcinogens(cancer-causing possibly), to group 1 carcinogens (cancer-causing certainly). There is not yet a regulation on this matter in our country.
Sources
Association of Indoor Tanning Regulations With Health and Economic Outcomes in North America and Europe.
JAMA Dermatology. 19 Feb 2020.
2. Jeff Craven. Banning Indoor Tanning Devices Could Save Lives and Money - Medscape - Feb 21, 2020.
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.