Could Your Cat's Meowing Detect an Epileptic Seizure?

An epileptic seizure is a sudden, uncontrolled electrical disturbance in the brain, referred to simply as a "seizure." It can cause changes in your behavior, movements, or feelings and levels of consciousness. Let us examine a talk by Chevelle Winchester, who claims that cats can perceive these changes.
While a fourth-year medical student, Chevelle Winchester encountered a patient in their late 20s who had seizures almost every day while completing a psychiatry rotation with neurologist and psychiatrist Alan R. Hirsch in Chicago.
Speaking to Medscape Medical News, Winchester said, "The seizures lasted approximately 1 minute and were associated with shortness of breath and postictal (after-seizure) blurred vision." The patient also experienced temporary memory loss, saying it felt as though several years of memories had been lost, but the memories gradually returned within an hour.
Winchester said, "One of the things I learned under Dr. Hirsch's supervision was that you need to take time to observe these patients' environments and find out what is happening around them."
After asking the patient to describe their entire surroundings in great detail before, during, and after a seizure, Winchester learned about an interesting, unexpected element: the patient's cat.
The patient gradually began associating the cat with the onset of seizures. Winchester said, "It took four or five sessions for this detail to emerge."
The patient reported that pain and stress accelerated the seizures. The patient also said they had noticed the cat displaying particular behaviors less than a minute before a seizure began.
The Cat's Behaviors Signaling a Seizure
The patient stated that the cat meowed unusually, pushed its head against the owner's legs, or scratched the owner with its front paw. Less than a minute after this warning, the patient's seizure appeared. This behavior signaled that the patient should move to a padded place in case of a fall.
A Better Sense of Smell?
Winchester said, "The cat would meow and lie beside the patient as if protecting them, staying there until the seizure passed." Winchester also noted that the patient remembered the cat's unusual behaviors during seizures.
The patient stated that they experienced daily panic attacks and that the cat displayed unusual behaviors only before seizures, showing no reaction before a panic attack.
Winchester said that cats being seizure detectors was something they could never have predicted. Winchester said, "As a medical student, many things are new to me, but this was completely unique. I explained the case to Dr. Hirsch, who said it was great and told me to do the research and start writing up the case.”
Beginning their research, Winchester added, “I knew that dogs detected and responded to epilepsy, but I had not seen anything about cats. When I started researching, I realized this was because there was not enough literature about cats, and I asked myself why. I wondered whether there were more cases involving cats and seizures than I thought and whether nobody was talking about them.”
Winchester's research included examining newspapers and magazines to find everything written about similar cases. In the end, they found very little.
"We know that dogs have far more smell receptors than we do. However, cats have even greater sensitivity. This comes from their V1R (a class of smell receptor) receptors. Cats have approximately 30 V1R proteins, whereas dogs have only 9 and mice have even more."
Given cats' strong ability to distinguish smells, Winchester hopes their findings will open a new area of study into the use of cats in detecting diseases.
Speaking about their study, Winchester said, “What else could this ability help us with? I hope this small study is a starting point for more discoveries. I really hope to continue the research. This is only one study, but I hope it sparks people's curiosity and reaches someone who can take it further.”
Being Curious
Winchester said the potential clinical value of these findings is still unknown.
"What could this do to treat other patients who face seizures? We do not know how far it could go. Much more needs to be investigated."
Winchester said it was unclear whether the cat was alerting the patient before a seizure occurred or responding to it. "Because we could not see the seizure occurring in front of us, we could not say for certain whether the cat understood what was happening beforehand or whether it was responding to the “smell” of the seizure." they said.
Winchester and Hirsch were planning to perform ambulatory electroencephalography on the cat to monitor changes (electrodes are placed on the patient's scalp, and the brain's electrical activity is recorded while the person continues normal activities). Unfortunately, before further research could be carried out, the cat died, probably of old age.
Winchester said, “The cat's death created a real obstacle to our research, but I can highlight something I have observed in each of these unusual cases. The common factors in these cases were the interactions between neurology, psychiatry, and the environment.”
"I feel that doctors do not have enough time to listen to what patients experience in their surroundings and what they are exposed to. Yet when we have this information, we can put it together and work out what is really happening." they said.
As for the patient, Winchester said that they could have continued the study if the patient had another cat, but it was very difficult to take the case further under these circumstances.
Sources
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.