Does Using E-Cigarettes to Quit Smoking Make Sense?

Smoking causes many health problems and remains a leading cause of preventable disease and death. United States companies calculated lost labor and financial damage from smoking-related health problems, finding thousands of extra dollars in costs per person. Major companies therefore aimed to offer employees smoking cessation programs. A study involving 54 companies observed outcomes in 6006 employees who smoked, testing five methods.
Smoking Cessation Methods Tested;
- “Usual care” consisting of informational and motivational messages (813 people).
- Only e-cigarette use without access to other methods (various flavors) (1119 people).
- Various methods including approved nicotine replacement products or drugs such as varenicline (Champix) and bupropion (Wellbutrin, Zyban), plus e-cigarettes (1588 people).
- Payment of up to 600 dollars depending on cessation success (1198 people).
- An upfront deposit of 600 dollars into participants’ accounts, repayable on failure (1208 people).
Participants were randomly assigned to one of five groups. The 54 companies represented different sizes and economic sectors. Verification used urinary cotinine and, for nicotine replacement users, blood carboxyhemoglobin. Cotinine is the main metabolite found in smokers’ urine and can remain detectable for days after tobacco use stops. Carboxyhemoglobin forms when the oxygen-carrying blood pigment hemoglobin binds carbon monoxide.
The respected scientific journal NEJM(New England Journal of Medicine) published the study, with 6-month cessation rates of:
- usual care: %0,7
- medication or replacement: %2,9
- e-cigarettes: %4,8
- rewards: %9,5
- redeemable deposits: %12,7.
These findings also question claims that e-cigarettes are better than traditional cessation methods. In lead author Dr. Scott Halpern’s words; “Do they help people stop smoking? The answer is clearly no; we cannot prove that they are better than conventional smoking cessation methods.”
In conclusion, researchers found financial incentives more effective and no significant difference between e-cigarettes and other cessation methods. The study also interestingly suggests that motivation may be more effective than prohibitions for positive behavior change. Company-level cost calculations found such cessation incentives highly economical for employers and insurers compared with lost labor.
However, this study tested e-cigarettes only for their effect on quitting conventional cigarettes. The health effects of electronic cigarettes are a separate matter. Increasing use among children and early adolescents is worrying, despite marketing promises of less harm. The earlier the brain encounters nicotine, the stronger addiction becomes.
Sources
Scott D. Halpern, M.D., Ph.D.
June 14, 2018
N Engl J Med 2018
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.