The History of Breast Cancer Surgery - 1

Because the breast is an easily identifiable organ due to its location, written records and examples of breast cancer even in ancient times are not very surprising.
Beliefs and Practices in Antiquity
The Edwin Smith Papyrus, the first written cancer record, concerned breast cancer and dated to 3,000 - 2,500 BC, approximately 5000 years ago. It contains original descriptions of breast cancer surgery. When “the breast is untouchable, swollen and cancer has spread throughout it,” the disease was described as incurable. In ancient Greece, divine help was sought for breast disease, evidenced by breast-shaped offerings to Asclepius (the Greek god of Medicine and Health) in Greek temples. Ancient Egyptian manuscripts from around 1600 BC describe 8 breast cancer cases treated by cauterization. In 400 BC, the Greek philosopher Hippocrates, the “Father of Medicine,” proposed that cancer was caused by imbalance of four bodily fluids (blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile). Particularly the idea that black bile caused cancer remained dominant for more than a thousand years.
Saint Leonidas of Alexandria in the 1st century AD detailed skilled, courageous surgical removal of breast tumors and cautery approaches. Removing tumors of certain sizes through wide incisions laid foundations for today’s oncological surgical principles. In 200 AD, referring to breast cancer, Galen concluded that accumulation of black bile in blood was a systemic disease. These ancient physicians accepted that cessation of menstruation was somehow related to cancer, essentially suggesting an age-cancer relationship. In line with this theory, Galen allowed surgical wounds to bleed freely to expel black bile and considered thread or wire appropriate for tying an opened vessel.
Surgical Stagnation in the Middle Ages
Between 476 and 1.500 AD, no significant medical progress occurred. Christian beliefs of the time favored healing through miracles and faith rather than surgery, perceived as barbarism. The Islamic world’s revival of Greek medicine through meticulous translation preserved medical knowledge for future generations. In the 10th century, the Persian Islamic scholar Ibn Sina (known in the West as Avicenna), Albucasis (Abu Al-Qasim Al-Zahrawi, Spain), and in the 12th century Maimonides (Spain) were three renowned physicians spreading medical achievement to extend Islamic accomplishments. Abu Al-Qasim strongly supported cautery in surgery. Using caustic paste to destroy tumors and make them operable recalls the same logic as chemotherapy for large breast cancers today. Abu Al-Qasim, Henri de Mondeville (the “father” of French surgery, 13th century) and Guy de Chauliac (France, 14th century) introduced unique instruments assisting rapid removal of breast tumors into the surgical armamentarium (all medical techniques, equipment and supplies used by a physician, institution and so on; the full range of supplies and equipment for a task).
The Renaissance: Celebrating Art and the Formation of Surgery
The 16 – 18th centuries were seen not only as nurturing artistic creativity but also as the golden age of surgery’s emergence. Surgical skill moved beyond the barber approach through anatomical exploration of the human body by Andreas Vesalius in Belgium in the 16th century. In England and France in the 18th century, Cooper’s breast ligaments and Sappey’s subareolar lymphatic network became established. John Hunter (one of surgery’s Scottish fathers) replaced “black bile” with lymph as the cause of breast cancer. Many theories, including thickened milk, trauma, personality type, air exposure and infection, fed the concept of carcinogenesis. Records describe many heroic procedures, from simple lumpectomy removing only the tumor region to radical removal of the entire breast with the pectoralis chest wall muscle. Remembering there was no anesthesia, these were impressive and admirable feats; skill and speed were essential in a successful surgeon. Another point is that surgery then offered the only hope of cure. Other recorded practices attempted breast removal through ligation (tying with thread or wire) or use of a lead plate.
For part 2, click here
Sources
A Brief History of Breast Cancer.
Sultan Qaboos Univ Med J. 2014 May; 14(2): e166–e169.
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.