Skip to content
Prof. Dr. Mustafa Özdoğan · Medical Oncologist

An Outlier Patient Advises: CHECK YOUR ASSUMPTIONS

An Outlier Patient Advises: CHECK YOUR ASSUMPTIONS

For years, Jacqueline Smith had patience and a sense of humor toward people who did not understand her medical history and said and did irritating things. She developed the disease twice before she turned 30. Her cancer was melanoma, stage 3. As a Black woman who developed this skin cancer, Smith acknowledges that the combination of her skin color, age and a range of other factors makes her “a complete anomaly” and an “outlier.”

Smith had the most common form of melanoma, known as superficial spreading melanoma, and acknowledges that she too once held mistaken beliefs.

"Until I was diagnosed with melanoma, I never believed that someone who looked like me was at risk of developing any skin cancer – I had never seen someone with an olive or darker skin tone in a single awareness campaign" she adds.

Now in her early 40s, Smith says her good humor and willingness to be understanding eventually turned into “resentment.” This was because it was not only ordinary people who were “shocked” or insensitive about her illness. Healthcare professionals and other patient advocates were too.

Smith describes sitting on a melanoma panel where “Pale Skin Rocks” stickers were handed out, and attending an advocacy event where people praised others for their pale skin and distributed T-shirts reading “Pale Skin Is Fashionable,” as "discouraging and dehumanizing".

The same applies to healthcare providers, some of whom gasped and exclaimed, "Wait a minute, did your skin actually burn?"

Smith confirms that such comments had a profound effect. "These interactions not only marginalized me in communities where I should have felt welcome and safe, but also silenced me." she adds.

As her patience was tested, Smith developed a view of what good healthcare means, in part because she had experienced poor healthcare.

During “ASCO Voices,” a storytelling session at the latest annual meeting of the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO), held virtually this year because of the pandemic, Smith says, “It all starts with checking your assumptions at the door.”

In her talk, Smith explained how this act of restraint leads to a range of good things that hold the promise of this year’s ASCO meeting theme: "advancing equity for every patient, every day, everywhere.”

Smith’s message resonated with ASCO Voices audience member Heather Hannon of the Women’s Health and Cancer Institute in Virginia. Hannon tweeted, "Thank you for sharing your thoughts, Jacqueline Smith. Your wisdom and insight are invaluable, and we must put them into action. 1. Check your assumptions at the door. 2. Consider quality of life in every decision."

A list of assumptions and misconceptions

Smith says she tries to practice what she preaches. Referring to her past lack of knowledge about melanoma risk and skin color, she explains, "I had to check my own assumptions before challenging others and theirs". She then described a series of assumptions and misconceptions she repeatedly experienced from healthcare professionals and other people.

First, Black people still develop melanoma, although it is relatively rare, she says.

Indeed, the melanoma rate in Black people is much lower than in White people or other ethnic groups. Overall, according to the American Cancer Society (ACS), the lifetime risk of melanoma is approximately 2.6% for White people (1 in 38), 0.6% for Hispanic people (1 in 167) and 0.1% for Black individuals (1 in 1000).

Moreover, although melanoma risk increases with age (the average age at diagnosis in the United States is 65), melanoma is “not uncommon even among those younger than 30,” says the ACS. In fact, it is one of the most common cancers in young adults, especially young women.

A 2009 study by William Anderson and colleagues at the US National Cancer Institute suggests that when melanoma develops in young people, heredity plays a role. "Melanoma in adolescents and young adults appears to arise among susceptible individuals through genetic interactions with early-life UV exposure" they write. The team also explained that “melanoma in older adults probably reflects cumulative lifetime exposure to ultraviolet light among those who are less susceptible.”

However, melanoma is not always associated with excessive UV exposure, and this is the second misconception Smith identifies. She was not a “sun worshipper” and had never used a tanning bed, as some had assumed.

Third, Smith also does not have acral lentiginous melanoma, as some have assumed. This is a rare form to which Black people are more susceptible than others, and it tends to appear on the palms, soles and beneath the nails. Reggae legend Bob Marley died from this type of melanoma after the disease first appeared beneath a toenail.

Fourth, Smith has always been health-conscious. “I spent years doing breast self-examinations, monitoring my salt intake and trying to get rid of diabetes” she explains.

Fifth, Smith’s melanoma spread beyond the skin. "Yes, people with skin cancer can travel, and melanoma can be more than just a mole" she says.

In a piece published by the Claire Marie Foundation, Smith said her stage 3 melanoma recurred at age 28, during her first semester in the sociology doctoral program at Syracuse University in New York. "I was devastated. The disease I thought I had beaten at 23 was rearing its ugly head again. Also, the lump in my bikini area that I had detected nearly a year and a half earlier was not the inflamed lymph node my gynecologist had assured me it was. Nor was it the result of a minor infection my family doctor had diagnosed. It was a lymph node filled with cancer."

Sixth, Smith, who looks like the picture of health from the outside, says she has “marks” of her illness, including surgical scars, radiation and interferon injections, as well as lymphedema.

Seventh, Smith argues that for a cancer patient, "simply surviving is not enough". This is an assumption her radiation oncologists held. "When I asked about the possible damage pelvic radiation could do to my ovaries and asked about fertility preservation, they said, “We do not have time to worry about that; we are trying to save your life.” Being complicit and compliant during that conversation is a choice I regret even today."

In her closing remarks, Smith said American medicine and society are working to “achieve equity in healthcare and beyond.” "It is time for us to work together to foster inclusive spaces. In doing so, we must open our minds. It is time to understand that outliers exist and deserve to be treated with respect and dignity."

Smith concluded: "As we work to encourage openness and amplify marginalized voices, we will begin truly to center the patient and cultivate the mutual respect, openness and understanding that advance equity for every patient, every day, everywhere."

*

Sources

Mulcahy,N. (June 15, 2021). 'Check Your Assumptions at the Door,' Advises Outlier Patient. Medscape.

Appointment request

DROZDOGAN AI

Explore this article together

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

DROZDOGAN AI

Drozdogan Assistant

An Outlier Patient Advises: CHECK YOUR ASSUMPTIONS

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

Conversation and privacy information

Drozdogan Assistant answers this conversation. Authorized site administrators may review it for quality. Do not share personal information.

Replies use OpenAI infrastructure. Questions and replies are processed by that service; conversation records are stored on our site. Do not share identifying, contact or personal health information.

0 / 1000

For information only; no personal diagnosis or treatment advice.

Related articles

Explore other articles on this topic.

Stay informed

Receive new articles and scientific updates by email.

Google Analytics runs on public pages independently of this window and may use analytics cookies. Your choice here controls external services only.

Cookie policy