Are diet drinks really “diet”?

Almost everything in daily life, from foods and drinks on menus to white bread, contains sugar. But are diet drinks, promoted as healthy alternatives to sugary beverages, really healthy? Some recent research says the situation is not quite as assumed.
In England, sugary drinks account for one third of total sugar intake among young people. In the United States, they account for almost half the sugar in Americans’ diets. Although very high in calories, sugary drinks contain no essential nutrients and increase the risk of being overweight or obese.
Many campaigns seek to raise awareness of sugar’s harmful health effects, particularly weight gain and obesity.
Sugary drinks versus diet drinks
Sugar is widespread in our diet, with 75 percent of processed foods and drinks containing it. Sugary drink consumption has also increased fivefold since the 50s.
Many studies have shown links between sugary drinks and cardiovascular disease, metabolic syndrome and diabetes. Diet drinks, by contrast, are said to be healthy and prevent weight gain.
However, the study discussed here says otherwise..
A study published in PLOS Medicine stated that artificially sweetened (diet, sugar-free) drinks were ineffective in preventing weight loss compared with their full-sugar counterparts.
Diet drinks are becoming increasingly popular alternatives to harmful sugary beverages. By 2008, the number of American children consuming diet drinks had doubled compared with 1999.
Why are diet drinks weak at promoting weight loss?
Diet drinks may stimulate sweetness receptors and trigger compensatory mechanisms. This can increase appetite and stimulate intestinal hormone secretion. Knowing that diet drinks are low in calories may amplify these effects and lead to overeating other foods. This chain of events may cause weight gain and additional obesity-related problems.
Based on results from various observational studies and meta-analyses, the team also states that diet drinks are associated with increased body mass index (BMI) and greater risk of cardiometabolic diseases such as type 2 diabetes and stroke.
Although studies cannot show that diet drinks directly trigger weight gain or metabolic disorders, neither have they demonstrated effectiveness for weight loss.
According to the authors, the perception that diet drinks are healthy arises from industry-funded and beverage-company-sponsored studies, which warrants attention.
In conclusion, the absence of definitive evidence supporting diet drinks’ role in preventing weight gain and the lack of studies on other long-term health effects suggest that it is too early to call them “part of a healthy diet”. I think it is useful to remember not to rely on diet drinks and shape our eating habits around that reliance.
Sources
Artificially sweetened beverages Artificially sweetened beverages and the response to the global obesity crisis.
PLOS Medicine, doi: https://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1002195, published online: 3 January 2017
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.