More Than Half of Covid-19 Transmission Found to Occur Through People WITHOUT SYMPTOMS

Covid-19 cases are rising and vaccines are delayed, so health authorities continue looking for additional ways to reduce the spread of the novel coronavirus.
A modelling study estimates that more than half of transmission comes from asymptomatic (symptom-free) individuals, suggesting that symptom-based screening will have little effect on spread. Asymptomatic individuals include patients who have not yet developed symptoms (presymptomatic) or silent carriers who will never develop symptoms.
On 7 January 2020, JAMA Network Open published online a study by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (US-CDC), which concludes in summary: alongside protective measures such as masks and social distancing, people with a history of contact or at risk – even the whole community – must undergo rigorous testing. Only in this way can asymptomatic individuals be detected and isolated.
In the absence of effective, widespread use of medicines or vaccines that can shorten or eliminate illness, successful control of SARS-CoV-2 cannot rely solely on identifying and isolating symptomatic (symptom-producing) cases; even if effectively implemented, this strategy will be insufficient. Multiple measures that effectively address transmission risk in the absence of symptoms are essential to control SARS-CoV-2...
Very strict testing appears to be the most important factor in China bringing Covid-19 under control – or appearing to do so. After new cases appeared in Wuhan following control of the disease, it was reported that 9 million citizens were tested within 1 week and the outbreak was brought under control again.
According to the authors, the effectiveness of some existing transmission prevention efforts is debated. They therefore decided to estimate the proportion of COVID-19 infections likely to result from individuals who have no symptoms and unknowingly infect others through modelling.
The study was thus conducted to establish a baseline assumption about how much transmission occurs from asymptomatic people, emphasizing the importance of mitigation measures and immunity through vaccination.
Analysis
Based on data from several Covid-19 studies over the past year, we know that 30% of infected individuals never develop symptoms, but 75% are still infectious.
The researchers then modelled multiple scenarios of transmission by presymptomatic and always-symptomatic individuals, assuming different incubation and infectious periods and varying numbers of days from infection to symptom onset.
When the models were combined, they predicted that 59% of all transmission would come from asymptomatic transmission: 35% from presymptomatic people and 24% from people who were never symptomatic.
The authors note that the overall proportion of transmission from individuals without symptoms and those who never become symptomatic is key to identifying mitigation measures that can control SARS-CoV-2.
For example, they explain that if the reproduction number of infection in a particular setting (R= the number of people one person infects) is 2.0, transmission must fall by at least 50% to bring R below 1.0. Given that R is probably much greater than 2 in some settings, and more than half of transmission may come from people who are asymptomatic at the time, effective control must reduce the risk of transmission from people without symptoms. This appears possible only through much more testing.
Assume that everyone is potentially infected
Experts agree that identifying asymptomatic individuals through greatly expanded testing is important. Screening to isolate symptomatic individuals is a sensible approach to help prevent spread, but these measures are far from sufficient because asymptomatic or presymptomatic individuals can still spread the virus, as clearly documented.
A person tested may unknowingly transmit infection because they have not yet become positive or because the result is falsely negative. When disease prevalence is as high as it currently is in the USA, a large proportion of those screened will also be infected unknowingly, so the proportion of false negatives may be high.
At present, visitors and staff in many hospitals, shopping centres and private or government institutions are screened with a thermometer at entry, and everyone has been required to wear a mask outside the home since the early days of the pandemic. Nationally, many hospital break-room outbreaks have occurred because staff eat lunch together, and these outbreaks also show the inadequacy of symptomatic isolation.
RELATED TOPICS
- Covid-19 Current Statistics for the World and Türkiye
- Breaking News and Scientific Developments About Coronavirus
Sources
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.