What Did Asian Countries Where the Coronavirus Outbreak Began Do Differently? What Lessons Should Western Countries Learn?

Shortly after the novel coronavirus outbreak began in China a few months ago, some Asian countries were able to bring its spread under control. Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan all kept case numbers relatively low despite their proximity to China, the virus's main source. Novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) cases then rose rapidly in Europe and America. After substantial increases in case numbers, Western countries took drastic measures, such as closing schools and cities.
Lesson 1: Take It Seriously and Act Quickly
Controlling the outbreak requires widespread testing, isolation of infected people and greater social distancing. Health experts agree on this. Similar measures are now being taken in the West, but timing matters. Many countries seem to have been late. Tikki Pangestu, former director of research policy at the World Health Organization (WHO), describes the situation: “After the outbreak began in China, Britain and America had two months, but they had the perception that China was far away and nothing would happen, and they missed an important opportunity”. China first reported a "mysterious SARS-like pneumonia case" to WHO on 31 December. At that point, human-to-human transmission had not been confirmed, and little was known about the virus. Yet within three days, Singapore, Taiwan and Hong Kong had increased screening at their borders; Taiwan was even checking passengers arriving from Wuhan before they left the aircraft. As scientists learned more about the virus, they discovered that people without symptoms could also transmit it, making testing even more important.
Lesson 2: Make Testing Widespread and Accessible
South Korea's first cases also rose very rapidly. However, the country quickly developed a test for the virus, and more than 290 thousand people have been tested so far. Approximately 10,000 free tests are still carried out daily. South Korea had experienced something similar before. After a MERS (Middel East Respiratory Syndrome) outbreak caused 35 deaths in 2015, it established a rapid approval system for infectious-disease tests. Ooi Eng Eong, professor of infectious diseases at the National University of Singapore, says: “South Korea's approach to screening the public and its speed of action were truly impressive.” America and Britain, however, followed a different path from South Korea. America initially delayed testing, and its first test kits were faulty. Private laboratories struggled to obtain approval for their tests. Many people had difficulty getting tested, and tests were expensive. Eventually, free testing for everyone was enacted into law. Meanwhile, Britain announced it would test only people presenting to hospitals, making it harder to identify infected people with milder symptoms. Professor Pangestu says, “Some countries do not have enough test kits. Yet extensive testing is the most important priority in outbreaks. Testing people who have symptoms but do not need hospitalization and are spreading the virus may be the most important way to stop the outbreak,” he says.
Lesson 3: Trace and Isolate
Testing people with symptoms is important, but it is not enough. Tracing their contacts is another key step. In Singapore, investigators used cameras to trace the contacts of more than 6 thousand people; suspected individuals were tested and isolated individually until their results were clear. Hong Kong similarly traced contacts, even looking back two days before patients showed symptoms. These countries also used compulsory measures to ensure that people asked to self-isolate stayed home. Hong Kong required newly arrived passengers from abroad to wear electronic bracelets so their movements could be monitored. In Singapore, people in self-isolation were contacted several times daily and asked to send photographs as proof of their location. Those who disobeyed the “Stay at home” order faced severe measures, including imprisonment. One person's residence permit was revoked for breaking the rules. Many Western countries, however, struggle to take such measures because of larger populations and human rights. Professor Ooi says of this process: “We can do these things because we have a smaller population. Other countries may not be able to do what we do. Therefore, each country must do what works best for it,” he says.
Lesson 4: Maintain Social Distance Early
Maintaining social distance is one of the best ways to control an outbreak. However, measures must be taken very early to work. In China's Wuhan, where the virus is thought to have originated, 5 million people had left before the city was closed. This led to the largest quarantine in the Chinese government's history. Italy and Spain likewise had to impose national quarantines after case numbers exceeded thousands. After being urged to stay home, New York and California residents ordered essential supplies such as legumes. In contrast, schools are still operating in Singapore despite the closure of most public places. Hong Kong has closed schools and encouraged employees to work from home, but restaurants and bars remain open. Professor Ooi says, “I believe these differences depend on how quickly governments implemented social distancing. By the time many countries increased control measures, case numbers had grown so much that they needed tougher steps,” he says. Government decisions to prohibit gatherings or close schools affected social distancing. However, alongside government messages, voluntary participation in restrictions, meaning individual attitudes, matters for success.
Lesson 5: Keep the Public Well Informed and Stand With Them
Professor Pangestu says, “Unless the public cooperates with you, people will not follow your policies and enforcement will only go so far. What matters is demonstrating policies based on scientific evidence,” he adds. “Because China was slow to acknowledge the outbreak, it was overwhelmed. A major political meeting in Wuhan even allowed concerns to grow. In addition, officials punished doctors who tried to warn others. After one person died from the virus, sparks of anger began”. The outbreak's spread slowed effectively after hospital capacity was increased and a large quarantine imposed. Critics, however, say these extreme measures were needed because the initial response was slow. In America, President Donald Trump frequently contradicts health officials about the number of available test kits and the seriousness of the outbreak. The government also gives conflicting information on how many people have been tested, and many private laboratories cannot submit data to the CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention). Professor Ooi emphasizes that transparency is important in fighting the outbreak and says it will stop people panicking and stockpiling. Some governments that chose transparency used technology to give the public detailed information. Hong Kong used an online dashboard with a map showing buildings where cases were located. South Korea introduced a mobile alert system enabling people to find out whether they had been near an infected person. Singapore's prime minister demonstrated clear and open communication about coronavirus in an encouraging speech aimed at stopping panic buying. Shared responsibility for national safety was emphasized. Singapore's measures received widespread public support, and the media supported them too.
Lesson 6: Individual Attitudes Matter Too
It is sometimes said that Asians are more likely to obey government orders. In contrast, Hong Kong has seen months of antigovernment protests and public trust in government is low. Yet in one of the world's most densely populated cities, people voluntarily maintained social distance, and some even avoided Lunar New Year celebrations, the equivalent of skipping Christmas. Professor Pangestu believes Hong Kong people are proud of their identity despite distrusting the government and see the outbreak as a threat to their identity and territory. Another specialist who worked in Hong Kong, Dr. Karin Huster, notes that many residents remember the SARS outbreak that hit the region hard in 2003 and thinks people have a strong "sense of personal responsibility". Masks are also known to be widely used in parts of Asia. Ms. Huster says this is seen as “respect for others,” and she has sometimes noticed people avoiding her in elevators because she was not wearing a mask. In contrast, she says people in much of the West do not wear masks unless they are ill. Experts in Asia agree that masks are much less effective than measures such as handwashing. They think such supplies should be used by healthcare workers, especially where supplies are limited. There are also differing views on whether wearing a mask makes sense. Benjamin Cowling, professor of epidemiology at the University of Hong Kong, says, “Masks are not a magic bullet against coronavirus! Although they may have some benefits, we do not have clear evidence that they are protective,” he says. Healthcare workers must nevertheless wear masks. Ms. Huster previously worked on the Ebola outbreak and said people need to wash their hands more frequently and maintain social distance. On social distancing, Ms. Huster says, “I think people in America are more individualistic; sacrificing our freedom will be much harder for us. It is very difficult to explain that people need to change their habits,” she says.
Is All This Enough to Stop the Virus?
Experts believe Western countries imposing more intensive measures will eventually slow the spread successfully. They can also look to Asia to understand the challenges ahead. Although the virus has been brought under control in Asia, countries and regions such as China, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore and Hong Kong are now facing a second wave of coronavirus because of new arrivals. It is also unclear how long this outbreak may last. Professor Ooi is more optimistic because numbers in the second coronavirus outbreak in locked-down Hubei Province began falling within two or three weeks. He believes other countries taking milder measures may also control the outbreak within weeks. “The second outbreak should be offered as inspiration to other countries right now: it may hurt, but it can be done.” Professor Cowling, in contrast, worries that local transmission could resume if quarantine ends too early. “I am not sure whether social distancing can be sustained for as long as necessary. Developing a vaccine may take 18 months. But we should not really relax until one is found. On the other hand, people in Hong Kong are already tired even after a good month.” The world is facing a truly difficult test The novel coronavirus pandemic harms public health, while prolonged quarantines harm the economy. Our shared priority should be to stop the outbreak as quickly as possible. People around the world should participate voluntarily in this struggle and take shared responsibility during this difficult time. *
Sources
bbc.com - BBC News, 21 March 2020.
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.