In Tackling Obesity, What Matters: Weight Loss or Exercise and Fitness?

In a recent review, researchers concluded that in tackling obesity, focusing less on weight loss and more on improving physical activity and cardiorespiratory (heart and lung) fitness would be more effective at preventing premature deaths.
Researchers endorse an approach they say is as effective as—or more effective than a “weight-loss-focused” approach for treating obesity-related health conditions: a weight-neutral approach. Robert Ross, an expert in this field, agrees. Ross says, “When managing obesity, it is wrong to use as the main determinant of treatment effectiveness an obsession with the scale”. A researcher at the School of Kinesiology and Health Studies at Queen's University in Kingston, Canada, Ross says this overshadows the enormous health benefits of improved fitness, independently of obesity.
“Increasing efforts to stay fit improves outcomes even if it does not produce weight loss.”
However, this approach has reignited differences of opinion about obesity interventions. A few days later, illustrating this disagreement, another expert review appeared on obesity and type 2 diabetes, strongly stating that for most people with these conditions, the primary intervention goal should be losing at least 15% of initial body weight. (According to 2020 statistics from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, more than 60% of adults with diabetes in the USA are obese.)
- You may be interested: The relationship between obesity and cancer
Nevertheless, in obesity management, combining these approaches and encouraging both weight loss and increased activity and fitness also raises questions about whether all or just one should be pursued.
Washington's National Center for Weight and Wellness obesity expert Scott Kahan says, “Dividing this into weight management or activity and physical fitness only muddies the waters." .
The Way Forward: A Weight-Neutral Path
Glenn A. Gaesser, Professor of Exercise Physiology at Arizona State University in Phoenix and a coauthor of the new review, says, "The most important new information (in the review) is the direct comparison of the significance of mortality-risk reduction associated with weight loss against increased fitness, physical activity or both." "The results are quite clear: increased fitness, physical activity or both are associated with a greater reduction in mortality than intentional weight loss. We argue that the way forward in obesity treatment is a weight-neutral approach. Exercise has no disadvantages, but weight loss has substantial disadvantages, particularly leading to an unintentional 'futile weight-loss cycle' after unintentional weight gain.”
It Is Not a Simple Problem with One Solution!
However, Kahan says comparing the mortality effects of weight loss with those of increased activity and fitness is logically flawed. "It is difficult to draw firm conclusions from observational studies. The data cited in the review of activity and fitness compared with weight loss are generally 'estimates' with 'a great deal of fuzziness.'”
Kahan also disputes the premise described in detail in the review: that aiming for weight loss and applying healthy, evidence-based approaches to achieve it is doomed to fail and will frequently lead to negative outcomes. “Managing weight in an appropriate, patient-centered, thoughtful way is part of the standard and core of long-term health.”
Nevertheless, Kahan acknowledges that the weight-loss marketplace is full of fraudsters exploiting many patients, and warns against approaches focused on weight loss at any cost and on selling products. Emphasizing that obesity management is not a simple intervention with a single solution, he said, “but focusing solely on activity and ignoring healthy eating is extreme” .
Not the First
This is not the first article by Gaesser and his team encouraging a move away from weight loss as the primary goal in obesity interventions. In 2015, Gaesser and colleagues published an evidence review offering this advice for managing people with obesity: "We suggest that responsibility for improving health should not be assigned to weight loss, but rather to improvements in cardiometabolic parameters, functional status and fitness."
- Related topic: Good nutrition and exercise may improve mental abilities – but how?
Gaesser's latest review also acknowledges similar recommendations from others, including Ross, who says it is not new to conclude that greater fitness and activity without weight loss is not failure. "It is something we have supported for many years," but "there has been no agreement or action in clinical settings. That is unfortunate."
More than 10 years ago, Ross and a colleague wrote in a review: "Focusing solely on weight loss as the only determinant of success for strategies intended to reduce obesity is inappropriate and, more importantly, removes the option of focusing on lifestyle behaviors associated with benefits across numerous health outcomes." He emphasized that an effective intervention focused on activity and fitness means that, at a minimum, patients should not gain weight, and they may lose weight as an additional benefit. "We always advocate a balanced diet so people do not gain excess weight." Ross also emphasized the value of fitness measurements as an alternative to regularly recording weight to monitor the response of patients with obesity to various interventions.
- Related topic: The best diets of 2020
Sources
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.