Skip to content
Prof. Dr. Mustafa Özdoğan · Medical Oncologist

Is Excessive Animal Farming Creating a Perfect Storm for Pandemics?

Is Excessive Animal Farming Creating a Perfect Storm for Pandemics?
  • Prof. Cock Van Oosterhout, a professor of evolutionary genetics at the University of East Anglia in the United Kingdom, states that centuries of intensive animal breeding have turned livestock into a "mixing vessel" for the evolution of pathogens that can jump from animals to humans.
  • Virulence is the journal in which he argues that emerging infectious diseases pose an "existential threat" to our species.
  • To minimize the threat, he advocates restoring genetic diversity to livestock and crops and reducing animal protein consumption.

In the wild, viruses and their animal hosts are in a dynamic partnership involving reciprocal, adaptive genetic changes that occur naturally when the two species interact.

As a result of the continual adaptations and counteradaptations between viruses and their host species, neither gains a permanent advantage over the other.

Evolutionary biologists liken this evolutionary stalemate to the race in Lewis Carroll's book "Alice Looking into the Mirror", where the Red Queen describes it as: "Having to keep running just to stay in the same place."

Virulence published his editorial warning that our highly bred livestock cannot keep pace with the evolution of microorganisms such as viruses because of their lack of genetic diversity.

As a result, livestock act as "mixing vessels" for the emergence of new infectious diseases that may subsequently jump from animals to humans.

Prof. Van Oosterhout says that, together with habitat and nature destruction, illegal wildlife trade, and mass migration of both animals and people, this creates a "perfect storm" for the development of pandemics such as COVID-19.

He concludes that emerging infectious diseases are "probably the greatest existential threat to humanity".

Severe Inbreeding

The Earth and Life Systems Alliance's vice president, Prof. Van Oosterhout, writes that livestock are severely inbred as a result of centuries of selective breeding.

Although the total biomass of livestock is 10 times that of all wildlife on Earth, research shows that the effective population size of these breeds—a measure of a population's genetic diversity and viability—is 80 times lower than the minimum viable population.

With so little genetic diversity, livestock cannot evolve to overcome the challenges posed by new pathogens.

Prof. Van Oosterhout writes:

"Given the extraordinarily high biomass of our livestock (and of us humans), the immediate fitness gains that parasitic microorganisms can achieve by exploiting this abundant resource are truly astronomical. Pathogenic microorganisms will continue adapting to exploit these resources, and it is high time we recognized this evolutionary inevitability."

He believes that everyone must make compromises "to safeguard the future well-being of our species".

He proposes three broad strategies to minimize the threat from future pandemics and the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic:

  • Control and reduce pathogen gene flow.
  • Restore genetic diversity in livestock.
  • Reduce animal protein consumption.

Control and Reduce Gene Flow

"Gene flow" is the mixing of the gene pools of different populations as a result of the movement of plants, animals, people, and their associated pathogens.

This genetic mixing creates opportunities for disease spread and the emergence of new infections.

Prof. Van Oosterhout writes that technology enabling virtual work is a simple and relatively easy way to control gene flow.

However, he acknowledges that other measures will involve policymakers making trade-offs between the benefits of economic growth, prosperity, and education and the potential costs to human health and the environment.

He suggests that governments should consider more controversial measures such as mandatory vaccination and vaccine passports.

Know Your Enemy

To monitor gene flow, Prof. Van Oosterhout writes that governments should allocate more resources to sequencing viruses harbored in wildlife and livestock.

"There are an estimated 1.67 million virus species; these await discovery in mammalian and avian hosts, and the cost of sequencing the viruses with the highest zoonotic potential could be enormous (~ 1.2 to 7 billion United States dollars), but this is a very small cost compared with a pandemic."

The destruction of nature and habitats is known to promote the emergence of new infectious diseases. Therefore, halting the loss of natural habitats will also be necessary to minimize gene flow, he writes.

Restore Genetic Diversity

Prof. Van Oosterhout argues that livestock farming has become a "sitting duck" for new pandemics, with infectious diseases emerging as a result of extremely low genetic diversity.

"Unless we act now, major crop and livestock losses are an evolutionary inevitability", he writes.

Fortunately, he says, much of the diversity once present in livestock and crops still exists in the wild species and relatives of these animals and plants and is distributed among different breeds.

Consume Less Animal Protein

While mass food production underpins our success as a species, it is unsustainable on environmental, ecological, and evolutionary grounds, he writes.

"We urgently need to reduce our reliance on animal protein, particularly the consumption of other mammals", he says.

He argues that, unlike fish, for example, mammals pose the greatest threat for the evolution and transmission of new infectious diseases because they are our closest relatives.

He also notes that the use of antibiotics to promote growth and control infections has led to new, more virulent, and more resistant microorganisms.

An Existential Threat?

Prof. Jonathan Stoyei of the Francis Crick Institute in London, England, studies the evolutionary "arms race" between viruses such as HIV and their hosts. Both viruses (HIV and SARS-CoV-2) "jumped" from animals to humans.

Finally, the author said, "I think we need to be very careful about talking about existential threats, particularly in the context of a virus that kills fewer than 2% of those infected. In general, I believe that ecological changes resulting from changing land use or deforestation pose a much greater threat than the theoretical risks associated with potential intermediate hosts having to come into close contact.".

RELATED TOPICS

Sources

1. Mitigating the threat of emerging infectious diseases; a coevolutionary perspective. Cock Van Oosterhout. Virulence, 19 April 2021.

2. Written by James Kingsland on May 10, 2021 — Fact checked by Alexandra Sanfins, Ph.D. Excessive animal farming created ‘perfect storm’ for pandemics, scientist says. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/

Appointment request

DROZDOGAN AI

Explore this article together

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

DROZDOGAN AI

Drozdogan Assistant

Is Excessive Animal Farming Creating a Perfect Storm for Pandemics?

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

Conversation and privacy information

Drozdogan Assistant answers this conversation. Authorized site administrators may review it for quality. Do not share personal information.

Replies use OpenAI infrastructure. Questions and replies are processed by that service; conversation records are stored on our site. Do not share identifying, contact or personal health information.

0 / 1000

For information only; no personal diagnosis or treatment advice.

Related articles

Explore other articles on this topic.

Stay informed

Receive new articles and scientific updates by email.

Google Analytics runs on public pages independently of this window and may use analytics cookies. Your choice here controls external services only.

Cookie policy