Skip to content
Prof. Dr. Mustafa Özdoğan · Medical Oncologist

What Is a Vaccine Passport? What Should It Cover? Ethical Debates during COVID-19

What Is a Vaccine Passport? What Should It Cover? Ethical Debates during COVID-19

As more people around the world complete their COVID-19 vaccinations, debate over "vaccine passports" has intensified. This brings ethical dilemmas.

Mark A. Hall of Wake Forest University's Schools of Law and Medicine and David M. Studdert of Stanford University's Schools of Law and Medicine, on 31 March 2021 in the New England Journal of Medicine, one of the world's leading medical journals, outline some of the most important ethical considerations in an article published online.

Vaccine Passports and the Desire to Return to Normality

As the COVID-19 pandemic enters its next phase, the desire to return to normality and the rollout of effective vaccines have sparked debate about vaccine passports.

Vaccine passports are vaccination certificates that reduce public health restrictions for their holders.

The Biden administration, the British government, and the European Union are currently evaluating their feasibility. Australia, Denmark, and Sweden have committed to the practice, and Israel, the world leader in vaccination per capita, is already issuing "green passes" to vaccinated citizens.

Although "fitness for travel" has been the primary focus of vaccine passports to date, some use of passports to regulate access to social and recreational gatherings, workplaces, or schools appears imminent. For example, Israel's green passes permit entry to otherwise restricted places such as hotels, gyms, restaurants, theaters, and live music venues, while a similar model in New York permits attendance at theaters, arenas, event venues, and large weddings.

Why a Vaccine Passport?

The basic rationale for these programs is that public health restrictions limiting freedoms and socially valuable activities should be tailored to verifiable risk.

Generally, such tailoring is not a controversial goal; it has long been a central principle of civil rights law and public health practice. The case for tailoring restrictions is particularly compelling when restrictions are severe, widespread public sentiment calls for some relief, and relaxing restrictions is likely to be safe for some identifiable people but not everyone.

Concerns about Vaccine Passports

Nevertheless, using COVID-19 vaccine passports to tailor restrictions has prompted vigorous debate grounded in several serious concerns:

  1. First, while vaccine supply remains limited, privileging people fortunate enough to gain early access is morally questionable.
  2. Second, even after supply constraints ease, vaccination rates among racial minorities and low-income populations seem likely to remain disproportionately low. Relatedly, if history is a guide, programs that confer social privileges based on "fitness" may lead to unfair discrimination.
  3. Third, the extent of protection provided by vaccination, particularly against new variants, and the potential for vaccinated people to transmit the virus are not yet fully understood.
  4. Fourth, granting privileges to vaccinated people would penalize those with religious or philosophical objections to vaccination.
  5. Fifth, for people who have received vaccines not approved by the FDA (the Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine, China's Sinovac vaccine, or Russia's Sputnik V vaccine), it remains unclear whether national vaccine passports issued to them would be valid internationally.
  6. Sixth, should vaccine passports be issued on the basis of vaccination or antibodies developed against COVID-19 ? In other words, vaccine passports should cover not only those vaccinated but also those who have had the infection; but for how long?
  7. Finally, we lack a consensus approach to accurately certifying vaccination.

Can Vaccine Passports Confer Privileges?

The public appears deeply divided over the appropriateness of immunity privileges. Last summer, we sought views from a nationally representative panel. Public support in the survey on COVID-19 certification programs based on positive tests for antibodies did not exceed half. Moreover, unlike views on many other pandemic control policies, disagreement about immunity passports crosses ideological, racial, and socioeconomic boundaries. The survey was conducted at an earlier stage of the pandemic and did not explicitly address vaccine-derived immunity, but newer surveys that do so have also revealed deeply divided opinions.

The Nature and Degree of Immunity Provided by Vaccination Need to Be Better Understood

Mixed opinions and competing arguments suggest that adopting an official government policy requiring widespread use of vaccine passports would be premature and highly unlikely in the United States. This confusion over vaccine passports is not unique to the United States. On the other hand, we believe the objections raised are insufficient to justify banning every use of vaccination certification, as some commentators have proposed.

Access to vaccines is rapidly increasing, with particular efforts to reach disadvantaged groups. Although the nature of immunity provided by vaccination and its degree need to be better understood, it seems clear enough that vaccination substantially reduces risk, particularly for severe COVID-19.

Reliable, accurate certification mechanisms are important. However, developing such mechanisms is largely a technical matter—a problem some leading technology companies are addressing—and should not entirely block an otherwise sensible policy. Finally, asking people who decline vaccination to bear restrictions as a consequence of that refusal seems only fair, particularly if such hesitancy collectively makes herd immunity unattainable.

It is therefore relatively easy to reject extreme policy positions—a broad mandatory public scheme or a ban on all private uses of certification. But how should policymakers navigate the broad, complex space in between? What is acceptable or optimal regarding vaccine passports may vary greatly by context. Two features of this landscape are especially important in assessing the appropriateness of policy moves: the nature of the privileged activities and the identity of the regulator.

Would Requiring Vaccine Passports Increase Vaccination Rates?

An important starting point is distinguishing passports from mandates. When the government makes participation in essential activities such as work or education conditional, certification essentially functions as a mandatory vaccination program. The legal and ethical perils of a government mandate for SARS-CoV-2 vaccines have been thoroughly reviewed elsewhere. Here, therefore, we focus on policy uses of vaccination certification other than government restrictions on physical access to essential settings such as workplaces, schools, and healthcare facilities.

The Passport Concept Applies Most Clearly to TRAVEL

Many countries impose quarantine requirements on people crossing international borders. A vaccine passport is intended to create an exemption from quarantine. However, countries have not reached a consensus on this. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (US-CDC) accepts having had COVID-19 as a reason to waive quarantine, and for travel from most countries the agency recommended lifting restrictions on people who have recovered from COVID-19. It seems only a matter of time before the same principles apply to travelers who can show proof of completed vaccination.

While taking the lead on vaccination-related travel policy, government can begin by establishing standards for reliable documentation of vaccination. Such standards are likely to emerge relatively soon from a public-private partnership in the travel industry and then spread to other settings.

Vaccine Passports beyond Travel

These other settings include social and recreational gatherings. Here, the case for government control is weaker because frontline policymaking and implementation more naturally fall to individual or collective participants. It would be reasonable to allow sports leagues, concert halls, gyms, clubs, restaurants, and bars to set rules governing access according to customers' vaccination status; doing so might also support broader efforts to encourage vaccination. Although not the main actors, governments will need to help guide the way. Individual or collective participants need standards and limits, including clear guidelines prohibiting uses of vaccination certification that constitute unlawful discrimination. More generally, government can help reduce inequalities arising from private certification by increasing vaccine supply and distribution and redoubling efforts to reach underserved populations.

Furthermore, to avoid conflicting with disability discrimination laws, employers' vaccination policies must be based on actual risks to workers' or customers' health. As certification programs proliferate, additional guidance will be needed alongside diligent enforcement of rules, including attention to complaints and whistleblower reports.

Another important role for government is ensuring that the architects of certification rules have ready access to the best and most current scientific knowledge about vaccine effectiveness and limitations. In distilling this knowledge, government should acknowledge that its primary aim in guiding individual or collective participants is not the complete elimination of risk. Rather, the social complexity of COVID-19 calls for guidance on gradations of risk that different participants may reasonably wish to avoid.

Finally, flexible adaptation is key. The past year has taught us that pandemic policies that make sense one month may need reconsideration the next. Rational and ethical vaccination certification policy will change regularly as vaccine availability increases, herd immunity draws nearer, and scientific evidence on effectiveness or limitations grows. Determining how long vaccines remain effective and how well they protect against new variants will be critical. But knowing that change is inevitable is no justification for withholding guidance until circumstances become clear. Current conditions call for immediate policies that offer a reasonable space for balancing public health protection with a return to prepandemic life.

RELATED TOPICS

Sources

Hall, M.A. Studdert, D.M. (2021). “Vaccine Passport” Certification — Policy and Ethical Considerations. N Engl J Med. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMp2104289

Appointment request

DROZDOGAN AI

Explore this article together

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

DROZDOGAN AI

Drozdogan Assistant

What Is a Vaccine Passport? What Should It Cover? Ethical Debates during COVID-19

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

Conversation and privacy information

Drozdogan Assistant answers this conversation. Authorized site administrators may review it for quality. Do not share personal information.

Replies use OpenAI infrastructure. Questions and replies are processed by that service; conversation records are stored on our site. Do not share identifying, contact or personal health information.

0 / 1000

For information only; no personal diagnosis or treatment advice.

Related articles

Explore other articles on this topic.

Stay informed

Receive new articles and scientific updates by email.

Google Analytics runs on public pages independently of this window and may use analytics cookies. Your choice here controls external services only.

Cookie policy