Skip to content
Prof. Dr. Mustafa Özdoğan · Medical Oncologist

Which diet is healthy for weight loss: Low fat or low carbohydrate?

Which diet is healthy for weight loss: Low fat or low carbohydrate?

The debate between low-fat, plant-based diets and low-carbohydrate, animal-based diets has been going on for a long time. High-glycemic-index carbohydrates (which raise blood sugar quickly) are thought to cause fat storage in the body and obesity by increasing insulin release after meals. On the other hand, 1 gram of carbohydrate and 1 gram of protein contain 4 calories whereas 1 gram of fat contains 9 calories. Therefore, dietary patterns high in fat, such as the ketogenic diet, may have a higher total calorie content.

Is all weight loss healthy?

While low-fat, plant-based diets are argued to be more beneficial for health, low-carbohydrate, animal-based diets are argued to produce faster weight loss and maintain better blood sugar balance.

 So what is the truth? How much truth is there in these claims about these dietary patterns?  To answer all these questions, we have compiled for our readers the results of a recent article in “Nature Medicine” journal.

2021 was the year this study was published. Its main aim was to investigate the effects of low-fat, plant-based diets and low-carbohydrate, animal-based diets on total daily calorie intake.

This study, in which the average age was 30, involved 20 participants. With an average Body Mass Index (VKİ) of 27.8 kg m2, the overweight participants, for 2 weeks, were assigned to different dietary groups. However, one participant left the study because of hypoglycemia (low blood sugar).

  • Participants in the first group followed a low-fat, plant-based diet (10.3% fat, 75.2% carbohydrate, 14.5% protein) as their eating pattern;
  • Participants in the second group followed a low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet (75.8% fat, 10.0% carbohydrate, 14.2% protein) as their eating pattern.

The low-fat dietary pattern contained only plant-based foods, while, of the foods in the low-carbohydrate dietary pattern, 82% came from animal sources. The common feature of the two dietary patterns was their low processed-food content.

Comparison of total energy intake

At the end of 2 weeks, the total calories consumed by participants following the 2 different dietary patterns were calculated.

The study concluded that participants following the low-fat, plant-based dietary pattern consumed, on average, 689 ± 73 fewer calories per day.

In addition, total calorie intake in weeks 1 and 2 was evaluated among participants following the same dietary pattern. The evaluation found no difference in total daily calorie intake between weeks 1 and 2 among participants following the low-fat, plant-based dietary pattern; in contrast, participants following the low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet consumed, in week 2 compared with week 1, 312±46 fewer calories per day.

comparison of low-carbohydrate and low-fat diets in terms of total daily energy intake

In the figure above, the graph shows that people following a low-carbohydrate, animal-based diet (such as ketogenic) had a higher total daily energy intake.

Comparison in terms of weight loss

When participants' weight loss over the 2-week period was evaluated at the end of the study, those following the low-fat dietary pattern lost an average of 1.09±0.32 kg; those following the low-carbohydrate pattern lost an average of 1.77±0.32 kg . Slightly greater weight loss was observed in the ketogenic-diet group.

how much weight is lost with which diet low fat or ketogenic

Losing muscle while trying to avoid carbohydrates…

To determine, after following the two different dietary patterns, where the total weight loss came from, researchers used a DEXA scan. Although DEXA scanning is mainly known as a device used to measure bone density, it can also be used to measure a person's body compartments, lean mass and fat mass.

The scan showed that the total weight loss of participants following the low-fat, plant-based dietary pattern came from fat mass, whereas weight loss among participants following the low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet came mostly from muscle mass.

low-fat versus ketogenic diet how much fat is lost

In the figure above, people who chose a low-carbohydrate (ketogenic) dietary pattern can be seen not to have lost weight in an ideal way, because only a small amount of their weight loss occurred in fat tissue.

Why did the keto diet fail?

In fact, according to the idea that high-carbohydrate foods raise insulin levels and are stored as fat mass, the result should have been the exact opposite. However, the study results show that the reality differs from this theory. Yes, carbohydrates consumed in excess are stored as fat. However, if the daily calorie requirement is not exceeded, they are not stored as fat but used for energy.

The foods from which carbohydrates come matter

The carbohydrates in this study came from healthy, plant-based foods, and consumption of packaged food was restricted. On the other hand, it was a striking result that people following the low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet lost muscle mass despite their high protein intake. The most meaningful explanation for this result is that on low-carbohydrate diets such as the ketogenic diet, the body uses carbohydrates within muscle and therefore loses muscle and water.

When it comes to healthy weight loss, the main goal of people dieting should be to lose weight while contributing to their health. Healthy weight loss is weight lost from fat mass, not muscle and water. Therefore, during the weight-loss process, it is important to know not only how much weight is lost, but also where it is lost from.

Commentary & Summary

Looking at the results of the study discussed in this article, we see no very marked difference in weight loss between low-fat, plant-based diets and low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diets. However, what matters is not only the total weight a diet causes someone to lose, but also where that weight is lost from. The fact that weight lost with low-fat, plant-based diets consists of fat shows that this dietary pattern is a healthier method for weight loss. However, around the world there is a confusing array of as many as 100 diets marketed with various slogans. US News & World Report has been classifying dietary patterns according to their characteristics and abilities for 10 years, with a large team of scientists and nutrition experts, to remove uncertainties about them. This year, Us News & World Report classified a total of 39 diets, and on its “Best Diets” list, the ketogenic diet ranked 37th. Low-fat and mostly plant-based dietary patterns, such as the Mediterranean Diet, DASH Diet, Vegetarian and Flexitarian Diet patterns, managed to enter the top 10 positions.  “Healthiest” was the distinction given to the Mediterranean Diet, which has topped the list for years. The Mediterranean dietary pattern is low in foods high in saturated fat and sugar, such as packaged foods, processed meats and fried foods, and rich in healthy foods such as vegetables, fruit, dried legumes, nuts, fish, olive oil and skinless white meat. Moreover, no food is completely prohibited in the Mediterranean dietary pattern; only the amount consumed is restricted. This makes the Mediterranean dietary pattern much more sustainable, healthy and balanced than other dietary patterns. We therefore recommend following a Mediterranean dietary pattern both to lose weight and to help protect yourself from diseases such as diabetes, cardiovascular disease, cancer and bowel diseases.

Sources

1. Hall K. D, Guo J, Courville A. B et al. Effect of a plant-based, low-fat diet versus an animal-based, ketogenic diet on ad libitum energy intake. Nature Medicine, 21 January 2021.

2. F. Perry Wilson. Keto vs Plant-Based Eating: Is the Carb-Insulin Model Correct? - Medscape - Jan 27, 2021.

Appointment request

DROZDOGAN AI

Explore this article together

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

DROZDOGAN AI

Drozdogan Assistant

Which diet is healthy for weight loss: Low fat or low carbohydrate?

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

Conversation and privacy information

Drozdogan Assistant answers this conversation. Authorized site administrators may review it for quality. Do not share personal information.

Replies use OpenAI infrastructure. Questions and replies are processed by that service; conversation records are stored on our site. Do not share identifying, contact or personal health information.

0 / 1000

For information only; no personal diagnosis or treatment advice.

Related articles

Explore other articles on this topic.

Stay informed

Receive new articles and scientific updates by email.

Google Analytics runs on public pages independently of this window and may use analytics cookies. Your choice here controls external services only.

Cookie policy