Skip to content
Prof. Dr. Mustafa Özdoğan · Medical Oncologist

Seeking a COVID-19 Solution through Digital Footprint Tracking – How Does Each Country Monitor Its Citizens?

Seeking a COVID-19 Solution through Digital Footprint Tracking – How Does Each Country Monitor Its Citizens?

COVID-19 and Digital Rights

In our previous article on this subject, we discussed how data obtained from mobile phones have an important role in research into COVID-19 disease caused by the novel coronavirus. However, we also noted that these studies bring ethical and legal issues concerning the use of digital data. This confronts users with violations of digital rights.

What Is a Digital Right?

A digital right refers to people's freedom to access information, create content and publish the content they create in digital media through computers, phones and other devices. This right covers the following:

  • The right to protection of privacy
  • The right not to have one's personal rights violated
  • The right to protection of personal data
  • The right to express opinions on the internet
  • The right to participate in governance through the internet
  • The right to submit complaints online
  • The right not to be defamed on the internet

The footprints we leave online may be used with or without compliance with privacy policies, resulting in violations of digital rights. Every country has the necessary legal regulations to combat digital rights violations. However, in this extraordinary situation that has shaken the entire world and threatens humanity, protection of digital rights can be said to have taken a back seat in some governments' approaches.

Since COVID-19 began to spread, governments in different parts of the world have introduced measures to slow the virus's spread: a range of digital tracking, physical surveillance and censorship measures. Some of these practices may have been used appropriately, necessarily and lawfully. However, they were introduced hastily without sufficient consideration by legislative bodies.

In this article, we discuss the fate of digital rights during the fight against COVID-19 and include notes from a digital rights tracker focusing on this issue. We present a chronological summary of initiatives posing risks to digital rights worldwide.

31 March 2020 Update

In March, 21 new digital tracking measures aimed at stopping the spread of the novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) were documented worldwide. These ranged from apps tracking targeted individuals to the use of aggregated, anonymized location data (the "Google Mobility Change Report" can be seen at the end of this article). In March alone, 11 new reports of COVID-19-related censorship and 6 new physical surveillance initiatives were also documented.

Which Countries Use Digital Tracking? The Differences

As governments around the world took measures to slow the virus's spread, many turned to digital tracking initiatives to help monitor their populations. Measures included using aggregated mobile location data to track citizens in areas under curfew, apps designed to help identify the locations of infected people, and advanced mobile tracking technologies. Countries using digital tracking measures adopted worldwide are listed below.

United States 28/03/2020

According to a report published by the Wall Street Journal on 28 March:

“Government officials in the United States are using location data obtained from millions of mobile phones to better understand people's movements in America during the coronavirus pandemic. Information identifying the phone owner, such as their name, is not specified. The aim is to help officials learn how the coronavirus is spreading nationwide and use the information obtained to prevent the virus's progress.”

The data in America are thought to come from the mobile advertising industry and Google rather than mobile operators.

Brazil 27/03/2020

According to a report from ZDNet on 27 March: “The mayor of Recife said that at least 700,000 smartphones were being monitored to determine whether the city was complying with the stay-at-home order.” The report also states “The government in Brazil is working to develop a system using geolocation tracking to support actions related to restrictions aimed at slowing COVID-19's spread.” This system was developed by the Brazilian startup InLoco, and users “said that InLoco claimed it was 30 times more accurate than GPS and tracked them through a location map using any GPS or beacon.”

South Africa 24/03/2020

South African Communications Minister Stella Ndabeni-Abrahams told reporters: “It is important to say what we know and track people affected by the virus to help the health ministry. There are many infected people in a particular area. The telecommunications industry has agreed to provide data analysis services to help the government achieve this”.

Bulgaria 24/03/2020

According to a tweet by Dr. Vesselin Bontchev, Bulgarian authorities said they would have the power from 24 March to monitor mobile phone traffic metadata and internet connections without a court order. According to his tweet, “The idea is to monitor those in quarantine, but this limitation is not specified in the law”.

Pakistan 24/03/2020

A Pakistani citizen said they had received a nationwide message indicating possible contact with an infected person. The message stated “It has been observed that an infected person may have come into contact with you within the last 14 days. You are therefore requested to take the necessary precautions through quarantine.” The measure is thought to use SIM card location information (CSLI) and call detail record (CDR) data collection methods. The article continues, “Using CDR analysis, details such as places visited by a confirmed COVID-19 patient and the mobile phone numbers of other people in the same vicinity at the same time can be obtained from the patient's phone data”.

Russia 23/03/2020

The Russian government issued a notice ordering the communications ministry to develop a new contact-tracing system to help monitor citizens thought to have been in contact with infected people. According to Meduza, “the system will analyze the geolocation data of specific individuals from telecommunications companies.”

Singapore 20/03/2020

Authorities in Singapore released an app called TraceTogether to help track COVID-19's spread. Developed by the Government Technology Agency and the Ministry of Health, the app already has 650,000 users, according to its website. According to the Straits Times, the app “can identify people who have been close to coronavirus patients through wireless Bluetooth technology.” According to a video released by TraceTogether, “No geolocation data or other personal data are collected.”

- Related topic: How Did Singapore SUCCEED during the Coronavirus Outbreak?

India 20/03/2020

On Friday, 20 March, Reuters reported: “People suspected of having coronavirus in India have been stamped on their hands with indelible ink. They are also being tracked using their mobile phones and personal data.” The indelible hand stamps applied to citizens arriving at airports in Maharashtra and southern Karnataka include the date of the person's self-isolation. The Reuters article continues, “In the southern state of Kerala, authorities used phone call records, CCTV footage and mobile phone GPS systems to track coronavirus patients' primary and secondary contacts”.

Poland 19/03/2020

Poland's Ministry of Digital Affairs launched a new app for citizens in quarantine. The app asks users to send a geolocated selfie at random times throughout the day so authorities can determine whether they are complying with quarantine measures. Failure to comply can result in a fine of 5,000 PLN. According to Privacy International: “The system identifies both the person (using facial recognition) and their location. This is similar to a police officer visiting someone in quarantine.”

United Kingdom 19/03/2020

Sky News reported that the UK government was working with the major mobile network numbered 02 to analyze its users' location data. According to the Sky News article, “The project will not track users and will not be designed to do so.” An article published the same day by The Guardian stated that EE, the country's largest mobile operator, was discussing with the government how best to share users' location data. Privacy advocates are concerned that handing over large quantities of such personal data crosses a line that will be difficult to retreat from when things return to normal.

Hong Kong 19/03/2020

Everyone arriving in Hong Kong from international travel must stay home for 14 days to help slow the virus's spread. To track new arrivals, authorities provide wristbands that record a user's location and can share it with the relevant authorities. Violating quarantine can result in 6 months' imprisonment and a fine of 25,000 HK.

Italy 18/03/2020

On 18 March, Vodafone launched a five-point plan for Oto to respond to the COVID-19 outbreak. According to the press release, the company was already producing an aggregated, anonymous heat map for Italy's Lombardy region to help it better understand population movements and curb COVID-19's spread.

Israel 17/03/2020

The Israeli government approved new surveillance measures allowing the regime to monitor citizens by tracking their mobile phones. Originally developed to assist counterterrorism operations, the technology is thought to be capable of tracking calls and messages as well as the physical locations of all mobile phones in the country. According to 7amleh, a Palestinian citizens' digital rights group, the regime can also access citizens' cameras and headphones.

Germany 17/03/2020

The German mobile operator Deutsche Telekom announced that it had passed users' anonymized location data to the Robert Koch Institute, a research institute and government agency responsible for disease control and prevention.

South Korea 16/03/2020

On 16 March, Korean telecommunications and credit card companies were reported to be sharing data with the government to help track citizens' movements. A report in The Guardian stated that messages sent by South Korean health authorities and local district offices “led to an accumulation of personal information and social stigmatization”.

Italy 14/03/2020

Like those in Germany, the United Kingdom and Austria, Italian mobile operators were seen sharing aggregated location data with health ministries. In a country now recording more coronavirus-related deaths than China, the location data are intended to help local authorities monitor citizens' responses to lockdown measures to control the virus. The Guardian's report found that more than 40,000 Italians had failed to comply with the stay-at-home order.

Belgium 12/03/2020

The Belgian government confirmed that it would allow local mobile operators to share anonymized data with a third party to track the virus's spread.

Iran 03/03/2020

Iranian citizens received a notification from the Ministry of Health about a new app. Called AC19, the app is thought to collect citizens' live locations to share users' movements with the regime.

Singapore 01/03/2020

At the end of February, Singapore's Ministry of Health provided the public with information about victims of the virus. It subsequently turned this information into an interactive map so citizens could track infected people's locations. The map quickly went viral, raising fears that it could lead to discrimination, stigmatization and severe violations of digital privacy.

Physical Surveillance Practices

Many governments are taking increasingly extensive physical surveillance measures to slow COVID-19's spread. These include installing facial recognition cameras equipped with thermal sensors, surveillance drones used to track citizens' movements, and extensive CCTV camera networks to help enforce curfews.

Australia 30/03/2020

Australia's 9 News reported that Western Australian police forces would begin using unmanned aerial vehicles to help enforce lockdown measures. According to the article: “Unmanned aircraft equipped with flashing police lights and sirens will be used to patrol beaches, parks and other areas and will be able to warn people disregarding social distancing rules.”

United States 27/03/2020

According to a tweet from Spectrum News NY1, the New York Police Department is using aerial imagery to help enforce restrictions.

Belgium 26/03/2020

A tweet by the European Commission's Online Communications Officer Raphael-Antonis Stylianou showed the use of surveillance aircraft in Brussels on 21 March.

Spain 14/03/2020

The Madrid Police Force tweeted: “We will not hesitate to use every tool we need to ensure your safety.” The tweet also included videos of surveillance drones. The drones were equipped with speakers and issued warnings urging citizens to stay home.

Russia 21/02/2020

Reuters reported that Moscow's mayor had announced the use of facial recognition to ensure people stayed home. According to the article, the mayor wrote on his website: “Measures, including facial recognition systems and other technical measures, continue in accordance with the regime." According to one report, a surveillance system called Safe City identified more than 200 people who had failed to comply with quarantine orders.

China 20/01/2020

China has many surveillance measures, including drones, facial recognition systems and mobile phone tracking. China Unicom and China Telecom, two of the country's largest telecommunications operators, asked citizens in Wuhan to provide personal information to link to their devices for more effective tracking. However, many worry that these new measures will become normalized and continue to be used in the same way after the virus subsides. Wang Aizhong, an activist based in Guangzhou, told The Guardian, “This outbreak is undoubtedly an opportunity for the government to increase surveillance of the public. I think the authorities may continue this after the outbreak.”

Censorship Practices

The novel coronavirus outbreak has also brought misinformation about it. Information of uncertain truth or falsehood that is spread deliberately is one of the main tools used to misinform and influence individuals and communities in society. To control this, governments and social media platforms have tried to regulate online content closely and report official facts and figures from international health organizations. However, some governments have chosen to justify censorship practices aimed at silencing writers and controlling the flow of information.

Iran 25/03/2020

According to a report in Voice of Amerika: “As coronavirus spread in Iran, the authorities moved swiftly and aggressively to include an independent report by harassing, detaining and censoring journalists and social media users.” The report continues, "Tehran questioned or detained journalists who contradicted or questioned official reports, warned that those publishing statistics other than government figures would be arrested, and issued censorship orders to newsrooms." On 2 March 2020, it also blocked access to Wikipedia's Persian-language edition in Iran. The reason was that it was thought to contain misinformation about the state's handling of the coronavirus outbreak.

Thailand 25/03/2020

Human Rights Watch reported that Thai authorities “used “fake news” laws to prosecute people who criticized the government's response to the COVID-19 outbreak".

Russia 25/03/2020

The Committee to Protect Journalists issued a statement calling on Russian authorities to stop censoring media coverage of the virus. According to the group's statement: “Russia's media regulator Roskomnadzor ordered some articles removed from websites and social media and threatened fines.”

Cambodia 24/03/2020

Human Rights Watch documented 17 social media users arrested for sharing information about COVID-19 in Cambodia. According to the human rights monitor, those arrested and questioned included a 14-year-old girl because she “voiced fears on social media about rumors of positive COVID-19 cases at her school and in her province.”

Niger 24/03/2020

According to a report published on 24 March by the Committee to Protect Journalists, authorities in Niger had arrested a prominent journalist over his comments about the virus.

Uganda 23/03/2020

According to a digital rights advocacy organization, a social media user was arrested in Uganda on 23 March for publishing COVID-19-related content. According to the group's report: “After a COVID-19 case was recorded in Uganda, the country's telecommunications regulator, the Uganda Communications Commission (UCC), tightened social media censorship.”

Egypt 18/03/2020

Al Jazeera reported on 18 March: “Egypt revoked the press credentials of a UK newspaper and a British journalist and censured the New York Times Cairo bureau chief over 'bad faith' reporting about the country's coronavirus cases.”

The Guardian published a report by Ruth Michaelson indicating that the number of coronavirus cases in the country was higher than official reporting suggested.

Singapore 16/03/2020

The Washington Post reported that Facebook had been ordered by Singapore's government to block local access to a popular Facebook page. The State Times Review page was quickly shut down because the company would face fines exceeding 14,000 dollars a day if the social media giant made an unfavorable decision. Authorities claimed the page was spreading misinformation about the coronavirus outbreak. The page was run by Alex Tan, a well-known Singaporean dissident known for his outspoken, critical articles.

China 31/12/2019

According to a recent Citizen Lab report, the livestreaming platform YY began censoring words related to the outbreak on 31 December 2019. WeChat also quickly began censoring COVID-19-related content and expanded its efforts in February. According to Citizen Lab: “Many censorship rules are broad and effectively block messages containing the virus's names or information sources about it. Such rules may restrict vital communication about disease information and prevention.” This is a view shared by the international human rights advocacy organization Human Rights Watch. According to its recent report: “The Chinese government initially withheld basic information about the coronavirus from the public, left infection cases unreported, downplayed the severity of infection and denied the possibility of human-to-human transmission.”

Internet Restrictions

Access Now wrote: As the world deals with COVID-19's spread, reliable and accurate information is one of the most important tools people have to protect themselves. However, despite the urgent need for the free flow of critical health information, four governments continue to restrict internet access in parts of their territories.

Ethiopia

The Ethiopian government, which has long imposed internet shutdowns, has restricted access in the Oromia region since January.

India

In India's Jammu and Kashmir regions, citizens can access only 2G connections. Restrictions began in August 2019, and although connections have been restored, the slow speeds of 2G significantly limit the flow of critical health information. They can also be said to limit citizens' ability to communicate with their families during periods of extreme anxiety.

Bangladesh

Since 2019, the Bangladeshi government has shut down mobile internet connections and prevented refugees from using SIM cards in the Rohingya refugee camps. According to Human Rights Watch, these restrictions “disrupt critical humanitarian and emergency services. By restricting internet access in refugee camps, Bangladeshi authorities are putting an already vulnerable group at greater risk.

Myanmar

Internet access has been blocked in nine townships in Rakhine and Chin states since 2019 amid severe armed conflict that continues today. With internet restrictions continuing in the country, many of the most vulnerable will be unable to access critical information about the virus. Myanmar's internet shutdown is one of the world's longest.

As a general assessment, while European countries have used digital tracking measures to date, censorship of digital content has been more prominent in Asian countries.

Conclusion

In conclusion, many methods, both good and bad, have been tried and continue to be tried since the outbreak began. Which of them will work will become clear over time. We have once again seen how important it is for different scientific fields to work together at such times.

- ALL OUR CORONAVIRUS ARTICLES -

Sources

COVID-19 Digital Rights Tracker.
top10vpn.com - 20 March 2020

Appointment request

DROZDOGAN AI

Explore this article together

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

DROZDOGAN AI

Drozdogan Assistant

Seeking a COVID-19 Solution through Digital Footprint Tracking – How Does Each Country Monitor Its Citizens?

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

Conversation and privacy information

Drozdogan Assistant answers this conversation. Authorized site administrators may review it for quality. Do not share personal information.

Replies use OpenAI infrastructure. Questions and replies are processed by that service; conversation records are stored on our site. Do not share identifying, contact or personal health information.

0 / 1000

For information only; no personal diagnosis or treatment advice.

Related articles

Explore other articles on this topic.

Stay informed

Receive new articles and scientific updates by email.

Google Analytics runs on public pages independently of this window and may use analytics cookies. Your choice here controls external services only.

Cookie policy