Is It Time to Stop Ringing the Victory Bell at the End of Cancer Treatment?

In many US oncology centers, patients ring a bell at the end of cancer treatment to symbolize their achievement. New findings, however, suggest this may make patients feel worse rather than better. The psychological effects of ringing the victory bell were examined in the first prospective controlled clinical study, which found treatment-related feelings of distress that persistfor months and may even worsen. Lead author Dr. Patrick A. Williams and colleagues comment: “Ringing a bell on the last day of cancer treatment may exemplify a well-intentioned practice with harmful consequences.” In their article, they state: “We hypothesize that ringing the bell creates emotional arousal that reinforces distress caused by cancer treatment and subsequently worsens the appraisal of treatment.” This new claim contradicts the earlier idea that bell ringing improves patients' overall treatment-related distress. Instead, the findings suggest it becomes a flashbulb memory that stimulates, during treatment, neural pathways linking strong memories and unpleasant emotions. American Society for Radiation Oncology issued a statement in which Williams comments: “Rather than locking in good feelings associated with completing treatment, bell ringing seems to lock in stressful thoughts associated with cancer treatment.” Williams nevertheless said he was “not ready to call for a blanket ban on bell ringing.” However, clinics should stop overemphasizing bell ceremonies or “motivating” patients to ring the bell, he says, although many US oncology clinics do this.
The Aim Should Be to Preserve an Emotionally Unaroused State
Emotional arousal at the worst possible moments, such as the end of difficult treatment, worsens treatment memories. The authors suggest that ringing the bell at the start of treatment, before treatment-related adverse effects arise, might be better. They also suggest a simple ceremony or small gift at treatment completion might be more “pleasant.”
- You may be interested: 7 lovely Valentine's Day gift ideas for loved ones diagnosed with cancer The end of treatment may be the best time to discuss future risks, for example, recurrence / relapse risk!
The First Study Evaluating Bell Ringing at Treatment Completion
In the study, 163 patients (77 bell ringers and 86 non-ringing controls) completed a survey on the final day of radiotherapy. They rated overall distress, worst distress, and treatment unpleasantness on an 11-point numerical and verbal rating scale. The three assessments were combined into a mean distress score for each patient. Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7 was used to obtain baseline anxiety levels. At routine follow-up, patients completed a shorter survey with the same questions. Compared with controls, the bell-ringing group had significantly greater overall distress scores. Higher distress scores were more pronounced in these patient subgroups:
- compared with patients older than 60, those aged 60 or younger,
- women compared with men,
- patients with cancers other than prostate or urinary tract cancer,
- patients diagnosed through symptoms compared with incidental diagnosis,
- compared with those receiving > 60 Gy of radiotherapy, those receiving <= 60 Gy, and
- patients who had undergone surgery previously
Views Against Bell Ringing
Metastatic cancer patients' relatives strongly oppose victory bell ceremonies. Treatment generally does not end for patients with metastatic disease, and hearing others ring the bell on completing treatment may provoke anger, resentment, or depression and similar feelings. Comments on this news included: “Patients successfully completing cancer treatment will have plenty of opportunities to celebrate, but ringing a bell beside those still struggling is, in my view, simply cruel.” “At the center where my mother was treated, every patient received a white rose at treatment completion. It was a small, unobtrusive acknowledgment of their struggle…[but] quiet out of respect for those still fighting.” However, a bell supporter shared: “I hear the bell every day where I work, and each time it brings tears to my eyes and fills me with hope and joy. I cannot imagine it not being part of cancer treatment.” The bell symbolizes a resolution, but as oncologists we know that varying recurrence risks make it difficult to tell patients they are completely cured. Moreover, cautious statements at treatment completion, such as “no evidence of disease,” may be perceived as claiming the risk is controlled and cause patients to experience fear of cancer recurrence . More importantly, treatment completion may be one of the best times to discuss future risks. Another cancer patient focused on recurrence risk. Annals of Internal Medicinepublished an article in which stage 4 breast cancer patient Mary Beth Schaeffer said she “constantly” watched victory bell ceremonies while receiving intravenous chemotherapy. “The patient rings the bell. Nurses and doctors join in. Celebrations grow! But a third will return with recurrent disease. And join me,” she says. JAMA Oncologypublished an article by Kevin J. Gale, a University of Minnesota Medical School student, describing his mother's distress when another patient rang the bell. With stage 4 colon cancer, the usually stoic woman began crying. “Why them and not me?” she asked. This prompted Gale to conduct a survey. Through the National Cancer Institute, he contacted 62 cancer centers and learned that 51 had victory bells. “Why do oncology clinics place victory bells in chemotherapy rooms or lobbies, often close to terminally ill patients?” he asks. “Is preserving this celebratory tradition important despite the distress and tears it brings? Why would a cancer center want to adversely affect its terminally ill patients?”
Sources
Was this article helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve our content.





Reader comments
Share your comment
Your name and comment are published only after administrator approval. Your email address is never shown to visitors.
Be the first to comment.