Skip to content
Prof. Dr. Mustafa Özdoğan · Medical Oncologist

Honesty in Medicine – How Should We Approach a Patient with Cancer Who Returns After Refusing Treatment?

Honesty in Medicine – How Should We Approach a Patient with Cancer Who Returns After Refusing Treatment?

It suddenly came back to me the moment I saw him in the clinic. Head and neck squamous cell cancer had been diagnosed. Unlike many other patients I had seen, he had refused conventional (modern, standard) cancer treatment after diagnosis. Instead, he had chosen to follow advice from friends and family, things he read online and even recommendations for alternative treatments from some doctors (such ashigh-dose vitamin C and coffee enemas). Months later, when the mass on the left side of his neck became very prominent, he returned to the oncology clinic to learn about treatment options.

As I prepared to meet him, these questions troubled me: "Would someone who chose alternative treatments months ago despite recommendations from many doctors now accept our advice? Would he be open to hearing us this time, or would he be hostile and distrustful toward physicians without valid reasons?"

Expecting a contentious encounter, I mentally prepared myself as I entered the examination room. A tall, well-dressed man greeted me in the corner and said, "Hello, doctor, I’m glad to see you," . His high, wide collar concealed the swollen lymph node on the left side of his neck.

The patient seemed to defy the portrait drawn in his medical record. He was calm and composed, carefully focused on what I said. He spoke honestly about his initial decision to pursue traditional and alternative therapies: "I was scared," he admitted, expressing his regret honestly. He seemed determined to develop a "modern / evidence-based" treatment plan with the oncology team.

Being more educated may make people more inclined to seek alternative treatments, because educated people believe they are capable of making good choices. The more worldly and better educated a person is, the more they believe there is something they can do about cancer and begin researching. In a sense, this makes sense to them. (Dr. James Yu, Yale University)

After a comprehensive discussion, I said I would consult my senior attending and return. He nodded and thanked me for my time. But as I was leaving, he stopped me. Suddenly his expression changed, showing deep pain, and "I messed up, didn’t I?" he asked. "If I had received treatment months ago, I would have been much better off, wouldn’t I?"

His question stunned me. In fact, I had no doubt about the answer. In another setting, I would certainly have said that refusing standard oncological treatment had exposed him to the risk of cancer progression. But seeing his distress and concern about how my answer might affect his mental health, I struggled. I knew his decision had exposed him to unnecessary risks: people with cancer who use alternative remedies without modern cancer treatment have a higher risk of death (see the related study). Yet as an empathetic doctor, I felt the need to reassure him.

Everyone around me—my family, teachers and mentors—had always taught me the importance of honesty. But alongside their advice to tell the truth, they emphasized that honesty might not always be the best policy. Telling patients in this situation the unvarnished truth could endanger their emotional state without providing any benefit.

Still, I wanted to respect my patient’s autonomy and answer his question. As I tried to formulate an acceptable response, I could only think how devastating it would be to blame him for his present distress. Even the idea of telling the truth overwhelmed me with guilt. On the other hand, could the prospect of lying to a patient be entirely unethical, even when the patient voiced his fears? A single lie, even with the best intentions, was a line I did not want to cross.

I turned away, no longer able to bear the intensity of his gaze. I could think of nothing better to say and wanted to remove myself from a situation I felt ill-equipped to handle. "Patients have the right to make their own choices," I said something to that effect. As soon as I left the room, I felt a deep sense of relief.

In the weeks since his clinic visit, I realized I had missed an opportunity to help him. In retrospect, he clearly expressed regret about his decision. Perhaps he had not needed me to state an obvious truth. Instead, perhaps what he really needed was assurance from me as a medical professional that, despite his previous mistaken choices, I still saw him as someone worthy of respect and deserving of treatment. He may have feared that on entering the clinic he would not be taken seriously enough as a treatment candidate and would somehow receive lower-quality care. In failing to recognize his need for validation, I had actually had a good opportunity to strengthen his trust in the medical system.

As a radiation oncology doctor, I have seen the number of patients choosing alternative medicine over modern treatments for newly diagnosed cancers increase over the years. Despite my growing experience, I find these interactions extremely difficult. A patient with early-stage cancer who could be completely cured with evidence-based modern treatment may refuse it, only to return to the clinic months later. Although I do my best to persuade patients not to abandon standard treatment, I see them feeling guilty when they are sicker than when I last saw them. I wonder whether I could have done more to change their minds about modern evidence-based treatment.

When patients return to the clinic asking for help, I now make sure I do not blame them for their situation. These patients have already faced many difficulties and do not need the extra stress of guilt hindering recovery. Instead, if patients question their previous decisions, I focus our conversation on ensuring they know I will treat them like any other patient I see. They will always deserve the most appropriate treatment and can be sure that, whatever happens, I will never judge them for the past.

Only then did I realize that many of these patients were ready to accept modern treatments.

*

Belowis Dr. Kunal Sindhu of the Department of Radiation Oncology at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York, author of this article that we translated.

kunal sindhu md

Related Topic:

 - 7 Reasons People Feel a Need for Complementary and Alternative Cancer Treatments

- What Types of Cancer Drugs Are There?

Sources

Sindhu K.
Honesty in Medicine-An Approach to Patients With Cancer Who Initially Reject Conventional Treatment.
JAMA Oncol. 28 Feb 2019.

Appointment request

DROZDOGAN AI

Explore this article together

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

DROZDOGAN AI

Drozdogan Assistant

Honesty in Medicine – How Should We Approach a Patient with Cancer Who Returns After Refusing Treatment?

Ask about the article and read answers alongside published sources from our site.

Conversation and privacy information

Drozdogan Assistant answers this conversation. Authorized site administrators may review it for quality. Do not share personal information.

Replies use OpenAI infrastructure. Questions and replies are processed by that service; conversation records are stored on our site. Do not share identifying, contact or personal health information.

0 / 1000

For information only; no personal diagnosis or treatment advice.

Related articles

Explore other articles on this topic.

Stay informed

Receive new articles and scientific updates by email.

Google Analytics runs on public pages independently of this window and may use analytics cookies. Your choice here controls external services only.

Cookie policy